Bron beats him because at the end of the day, bird's career was cut short. bird's peak was ridiculous. we all know that. 84-86 bird was probably top 3 peak all time. imagine bird never had a problem. he would've played well till in his late 30's because he never really relied on his athleticism. but dude was a broken man.
bron's been on top longer and overall bron did more. We all know Bron isn't the greatest clutch player. But bron makes up for his overall impact to a team. Bron just makes everyone around him better.
this is no knock on Bird. if we are talking about pure peak value, bird is no doubt top 5 all time. but GOAT debate is more than just the peak value. it's the whole shebang.
i have no problem people saying bird > bron. most of them are 'peak value' guys. if that's the case then Shaq is absolutely top 4 all time. i can't find anybody having a better peak than shaq except jordan.
peak value
1. MJ
2. shaq
3. bird
4. wilt
5. hakeem
i think bron's peak was 2009-2013. he is still in his prime. i would say his prime lasts 4 more years. we are truly witnessing one of the greatest career ever in the nba. i fully expect bron to win at least 2 more rings. if i have to guess, bron will retire with 5 rings.