Handlogten's Heros
Well-Known Member
2019 Award Winner
20-21 Award Winner
2022 Award Winner
2023 Award Winner
2024 Award Winner
2025 Award Winner
2025 Prediction Contest Winner
Its one of those catch-22 problems because the reason you can build a great team around Rudy is he can cover for the weaker defenders so you can balance his offensive limitations by having more dynamic offensive players. If he could punish them more on offense then you can put more defenders on the floor.I don’t think the problem is the guy hitting the three inasmuch as Quin won’t let him commit to guarding him, and the subsequent challenge of poor perimeter defenders left without Rudy there when mentally their whole strategy is to funnel to him.
Here’s the way I see the problem with small ball:
1. Teams going small puts Rudy in an impossible position.
2. That impossible position exists only because our perimeter defense can’t do an average job.
3. Rudy can’t punish them on offense (and/or Quin hasn’t found any way to punish this [I’m in the latter camp, FYI]), so a team doesn’t sacrifice much to run 5-out.
Countering by going small does not address any of the issues above. If it does improve things, it’s only because the 5 is allowed to stick to the perimeter guy and/or the other guys are having to step up, knowing Rudy’s not there to back them up. In any case, small ball is either worse or better defensively. If it’s worse, it highlights the fact that Rudy isn’t the problem. If it’s better, it’s because of aforementioned defensive adjustment, indicting Quin’s defensive strategy with Rudy on the floor as the problem, and not Rudy. Change that defensive scheme and Rudy at the 5 defensively is better than any small ball 5 option.
Then there’s the counter that “you play small ball for offense and not defense” and we neglect the fact that the reason we lost that series was the defensive scheme above, and not offense.
Last year was a little exaggerated since our starting backcourt was on like 1/2 a leg. Jackson and others going nuclear was another issue... but yeah this is still a problem. I don't have great answers but it'd be nice to see us really try some stuff. And trying for like half a regular season game doesn't count... it needs to be over multiple matchups and multiple games. Don't abandon the trial the second you lose one game or get lit up for a quarter.
I do think Gay can help us with rebounding and as a secondary rim presence when teams go small and Rudy has to be a bit more spread out.
There is a balance between over-reacting and changing nothing... we've skewed more towards doing nothing. I think we have to try some things... and I'm not sure there is an answer but you have to discover that there isn't an answer... ya know.