What's new

It's a no-no...

TroutBum

My Member's Premium
Contributor
It's a no-no to ask anything during an interview, apparently. Why not just fax in a picture and a resume and call it good? What the **** is this world coming to?

https://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/sec...iew-questions-actually-illegal-201733303.html

During job interviews, employers will try to gather as much information about you as possible, so there's bound to be some questions that will require you to think.

But it's the simple questions that are often most harmful, and even illegal.

Any questions that reveal your age, race, national origin, gender, religion, marital status and sexual orientation are off-limits.

"If you look at the broad picture, the [interview] questions you're asked have to be job-related and not about who you are as a person," Lori Adelson, a labor and employment attorney and partner with law firm Arnstein & Lehr, told us.

[Related: Things You Shouldn't Say in an Interview]

If you are asked any inappropriate questions, Adelson advises not to lie, but, instead, politely decline to answer.

"Could they not give you a job because of that? Sure," Adelson says. "But if they do, they would be doing exactly what they're not supposed to do."

We asked Adelson to provide us with some illegal interview questions that are often mistaken as appropriate and judicial.

Have you ever been arrested?

An employer can't actually legally ask you about your arrest record, but they can ask if you've ever been convicted of a crime.

Depending on the state, a conviction record shouldn't automatically disqualify you for employment unless it substantially relates to your job. For example, if you've been convicted of statutory rape and you're applying for a teaching position, you will probably not get the job

Are you married?

Although the interviewer may ask you this question to see how much time you'd be able to commit to your job, it's illegal because it reveals your marital status and can also reveal your sexual orientation.

Do you have children?

Again, the employer may ask you this question to see your available time commitment with the company, but this question is inappropriate.

However, they are allowed to ask you directly if you have other responsibilities or commitments that will be conflicting to your work schedule.

What country are you from?

If you have an accent, this may seem like an innocent question, but keep in mind that it's illegal because it involves your national origin.

Employers can't legally inquire about your nationality, but they can ask if you're authorized to work in a certain country.

Is English your first language?

It's not the employers lawful right to know if a language is your first language or not.

In order to find out language proficiency, employers can ask you what other languages you read, speak or write fluently.

Do you have any outstanding debt?

Employers have to have permission before asking about your credit history and, like a criminal background history, they can't disqualify you from employment unless it directly affects your ability to perform the position you're interviewing for.

Similarly, they can't ask you how well you balance your personal finances.

Do you socially drink?

Employers cannot ask about your drinking, or even legal drug use, habits because these inquiries are protected under the American Disability Act.

For example, if you're a recovering alcoholic, treatment of alcoholism is protected under this act and you don't have to disclose any disability information before landing an official job offer.

How long have you been working?

This question allows employers to guess your age which is unlawful. Similarly, they can't ask you what year you graduated from high school or college or even your birthday.

However, they can ask you how long you've been working in a certain industry.

What religious holidays do you practice?

Employers may want to ask you this to see if your lifestyle interferes with work schedules, but this question reveals your religion and that's illegal.

They can ask you if you're available to work on Sundays.
 
It's a no-no to ask anything during an interview, apparently. Why not just fax in a picture and a resume and call it good? What the **** is this world coming to?

https://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/sec...iew-questions-actually-illegal-201733303.html

I had a phone interview last week with a company in Draper. I had already taken a skills test and filled out a long questionaire. (I completely detest skills tests. Look at my damn resume. You think I'm lying?)
So I do this phone interview with an HR chick, who asks me a bunch of questions about past conflicts I have had with bosses and co-workers and how I dealt with them. So I answered and told her how I made each situation work out well, and also said it was hard for me to come up with examples because i rarely have conflicts on the job.

I was doing the interview in my car on my cell phone. She gushed about how much she enjoyed our interview and promised to call me the next day to set up an in person interview.

2 days later, I get a call from the recruiter who set it up and he tells me off because they don't want to persue me any further.
Why?
First they were offended that I did the interview from my car.
Second, they thought I spent too much time talking about conflicts, so I must be a guy who causes a lot of conflict.

The recruiter was ticked, but I shut him down and told him off.
He was still mad so I told him I would no longer work with him, and sent an email to his manager stating the same.

Recruiters are such dumbasses. This guy is only 22, and knows nothing about how to interview for a software job. He would set up an interview and then tell me all these dumb things to do. I would just ignore him. But I won't let some stupid idiot punk tell me off like that.
For the most part, I refuse to work with recruiters. Robert Half has learned to not call me.
 
I had a phone interview last week with a company in Draper. I had already taken a skills test and filled out a long questionaire. (I completely detest skills tests. Look at my damn resume. You think I'm lying?)
So I do this phone interview with an HR chick, who asks me a bunch of questions about past conflicts I have had with bosses and co-workers and how I dealt with them. So I answered and told her how I made each situation work out well, and also said it was hard for me to come up with examples because i rarely have conflicts on the job.

I was doing the interview in my car on my cell phone. She gushed about how much she enjoyed our interview and promised to call me the next day to set up an in person interview.

2 days later, I get a call from the recruiter who set it up and he tells me off because they don't want to persue me any further.
Why?
First they were offended that I did the interview from my car.
Second, they thought I spent too much time talking about conflicts, so I must be a guy who causes a lot of conflict.

The recruiter was ticked, but I shut him down and told him off.
He was still mad so I told him I would no longer work with him, and sent an email to his manager stating the same.

Recruiters are such dumbasses. This guy is only 22, and knows nothing about how to interview for a software job. He would set up an interview and then tell me all these dumb things to do. I would just ignore him. But I won't let some stupid idiot punk tell me off like that.
For the most part, I refuse to work with recruiters. Robert Half has learned to not call me.

A few things.

Interviewing from your car is unprofessional.

The fact that they spent so much time on "conflicts" should have been an indicator that they are worried about you.

Not being able to get an example off the top of your head shows a lack of imagination which can indicate you cannot think "out side the box".

The recruiter may only be 22 but he knows more about interviewing than you. Why hire a professional to help you with something if you are not going to listen to him? That again shows that you cannot be professional or courteous.

So in short, you did not get the job, showed your lack professionalism and imagination and have given yourself a bad reputation with a company and recruiting agency within your field. Agencies do talk to each other my friend. You are off to a phenomenal start.
 
A few things.

Interviewing from your car is unprofessional.

The fact that they spent so much time on "conflicts" should have been an indicator that they are worried about you.

Not being able to get an example off the top of your head shows a lack of imagination which can indicate you cannot think "out side the box".

The recruiter may only be 22 but he knows more about interviewing than you. Why hire a professional to help you with something if you are not going to listen to him? That again shows that you cannot be professional or courteous.

So in short, you did not get the job, showed your lack professionalism and imagination and have given yourself a bad reputation with a company and recruiting agency within your field. Agencies do talk to each other my friend. You are off to a phenomenal start.

Boom, bitches. In other news, I laughed out loud while reading this.
 
A few things.

Interviewing from your car is unprofessional.

The fact that they spent so much time on "conflicts" should have been an indicator that they are worried about you.

Not being able to get an example off the top of your head shows a lack of imagination which can indicate you cannot think "out side the box".

The recruiter may only be 22 but he knows more about interviewing than you. Why hire a professional to help you with something if you are not going to listen to him? That again shows that you cannot be professional or courteous.

So in short, you did not get the job, showed your lack professionalism and imagination and have given yourself a bad reputation with a company and recruiting agency within your field. Agencies do talk to each other my friend. You are off to a phenomenal start.

This.

Craig, maybe stick to getting chicks to look like Lou Ferrigno.
 
A few things.

Interviewing from your car is unprofessional.

The fact that they spent so much time on "conflicts" should have been an indicator that they are worried about you.Not being able to get an example off the top of your head shows a lack of imagination which can indicate you cannot think "out side the box".

The recruiter may only be 22 but he knows more about interviewing than you. Why hire a professional to help you with something if you are not going to listen to him? That again shows that you cannot be professional or courteous.

So in short, you did not get the job, showed your lack professionalism and imagination and have given yourself a bad reputation with a company and recruiting agency within your field. Agencies do talk to each other my friend. You are off to a phenomenal start.

Truth

Amazing that this person percieved you as someone who may be cantankerous. She must have wizard skills.
 
Last edited:
A few things.

Interviewing from your car is unprofessional.

The fact that they spent so much time on "conflicts" should have been an indicator that they are worried about you.

Not being able to get an example off the top of your head shows a lack of imagination which can indicate you cannot think "out side the box".

The recruiter may only be 22 but he knows more about interviewing than you. Why hire a professional to help you with something if you are not going to listen to him? That again shows that you cannot be professional or courteous.

So in short, you did not get the job, showed your lack professionalism and imagination and have given yourself a bad reputation with a company and recruiting agency within your field. Agencies do talk to each other my friend. You are off to a phenomenal start.

eh, wrong.
 
Truth

Amazing that this person percieved you as someone who may be cantankerous. She must have wizzard skills.

HR Pro. She probably has a masters degree in how to spot jack-holes.
 
Did you get the job? No? Case in point.

Did I want the job? No. Case in point.

I have turned down offers many times. When I interview with a company, I am interviewing them as much as they are interviewing me.
I don't want to work for a dump.
 
oh, and I've gotten jobs twice from phone interviews I did in my car. Both turned out to be great jobs.

Now how did that happen?
 
Did I want the job? No. Case in point.

I have turned down offers many times. When I interview with a company, I am interviewing them as much as they are interviewing me.
I don't want to work for a dump.

Hold on, hold on! I need to get my hip waders.

OK, I am ready. If you did not want the job you would have told them no thank you when they set up the second interview. You probably would have contacted your recruiter, you know the professional you are not listening to, and spoken with him about not liking that company and wishing to pursue another firm.

Let's say you did not want that job. Well you just wasted that recruiter and software firms time. That is also unprofessional and adds to your growing bad reputation. I think everyone but you can see the pattern here.

The problem is not them it is you and your attitude. I did not single out your positions on anything, just your attitude.
 
oh, and I've gotten jobs twice from phone interviews I did in my car. Both turned out to be great jobs.

Now how did that happen?

That has no bearing on you being unprofessional in your interview.
 
The recruiter may only be 22 but he knows more about interviewing than you. Why hire a professional to help you with something if you are not going to listen to him? That again shows that you cannot be professional or courteous.

So in short, you did not get the job, showed your lack professionalism and imagination and have given yourself a bad reputation with a company and recruiting agency within your field. Agencies do talk to each other my friend. You are off to a phenomenal start.

Uh, let me tell you something about recruiters....
This particular one was a doozy. He first contacted me and I told him to buzz off.
I did not hire him. You don't hire recruiters.
He kept bugging me and finally I just said, "If you find some jobs, let me know."
He found a few and sent me on a couple of interviews. They were not good. One of them was so bad, he just sent me there and the company didn't even know my name or have my resume when I arrived.

Also, when this recruiter called some of my references, he pissed them all off by trying to recruit them. Each of them called me to say "Why is this jackass trying to sell me on his company?"
The guy was one of the worst recruiters I have ever encountered (and that is saying something). I have absolutely no worry about him trying to blackball me. It doesnt' work that way in my field.

I've told off Robert Half a few times. They are terrible and even if they had the greatest job ever for me, I would still not go through them.
 
Now are you saying you were in your car DRIVING while doing your interview? Yes, that is unprofessional. Not just unprofessional, but plain old bad judgement.
 
Now are you saying you were in your car DRIVING while doing your interview? Yes, that is unprofessional. Not just unprofessional, but plain old bad judgement.

No, I was sitting in my car. Not moving. I thought it would be a quiet place with no distractions.
If the company was professional, they would have had me come in to their office to do it face to face. Especially since they are located so close to me.

Are you done being a jackass?
 
No, I was sitting in my car. Not moving. I thought it would be a quiet place with no distractions.
If the company was professional, they would have had me come in to their office to do it face to face. Especially since they are located so close to me.

Are you done being a jackass?

For someone supposedly so experienced with interviewing, you sound like a novice when making an ignorant comment about phone interviews.
 
Back
Top