What's new
By:

1st Place Poll for Sandwich Draft

Who has the best sandwich?

  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .
Saint Cy of JFC

Saint Cy of JFC

Well-Known Member
2022 Award Winner
2025 Award Winner
Vote for the sandwich you think is the best. The sandwich you vote for in this poll will receive 3 points towards their total.

*Voting for yourself is against the rules and will result in a point being deducted from your final total*

1. Moevillini:

Ingredients:
* Pretzel bun (very lightly toasted)
* Smoked Gouda cheese
* Ham sliced off the bone (or your favorite deli ham, thick sliced)
* Grilled Peach (peel if using fresh, use half a peach or cut into slices)
* Peach Chutney (condiment)
* Butter Lettuce

Assembly:
Use either a toaster oven or stovetop. Bottom of bun spread with peach chutney, ham, cheese - grill/toast until cheese just softens and is melty. Top with the peach, butter lettuce, more chutney if desired and top of pretzel bun.

2. Gandalfe:

Ingredients:
* Marbled Rye
* Emmental Cheese
* Caramelized Onions
* Sir Kenisngton's Spicy Brown Mustard
* Bread & Butter Pickle Chips
* Katz Deli Pastrami

Assembly:
Straight forward sandwich put into a sandwich press long enough for the cheese to get "all melty and gooey"

3. Saint Cy of JFC:

Ingredients:
* Waffles
* Buttermilk Fried Chicken Thigh
* Pimento Cheese
* Jalapenos
* Fried Green Tomato
* Polyensian Sauce from Chick-fil-A

Assembly:
Straight forward sandwich (Waffle is the bread if that wasnt obvious), everything goes on hot besides the cheese, which will naturally soften up due to heat of chicken/waffles/tomato.

4. Spycam1:

Ingredients:
* Kobe Beef
* Toasted Brioche Bun
* Bacon (double)
* Sunny Side Up Egg
* Maple Syrup
* Fried Pepper Jack Cheese Cubes

Assembly:
A double bacon burger made from kobe beef; served on a toasted brioche bun with sunny side up egg, maple syrup, and fried pepper jack cheese cubes.

5.White Chocolate:

Ingredients:
* Corned Beef
* Swiss Cheese
* Sauerkraut
* Russian Dressing
* Pickle Slices
* Pumpernickel

Assembly:
It's a Reuben, try not to hurt your brain imaging this.

6.Rubashov:

Ingredients:
* Ciabatta Roll w/ Olives (toasted)
* Kangaroo Loin
* d'Affinois Cheese
* Garlic and Mustard Mayo
* Red Onions
* Iceberg Lettuce

Assembly:
Toast the ciabatta roll, shred the lettuce, fry the onions in a pan with some butter, slice the d'affinois and assemble. then add the BBQ'd Kangaroo meat and mustard, add some dice raw red onion to the mustard.

7.TheeJazzFan:

Ingredients:
* Toasted Hoagie Roll
* Brisket
* Garlic Roasted Mashed Potatoes
* Jalapeno Cream Cheese
* Spicy Barbecue Sauce
* Sweet & Smoky Baked Beans w/ Apple Smoked Pork Chunks

Assembly:
Straight forward assembly w/ only specifications being that the mashed potatoes go on both the top and bottom slices of bread.

8. Wes Mantooth:

Ingredients:
* Sourdough Bread
* Brie
* Proscuitto
* Fried Egg
* Fig Jam
* Arugula

Assembly:
Staight forward assembly w/ only specification being that the sandwich is of the grilled cheese variety and arugula proportions are "a little just for texture".

9. 8:

Ingredients:
* Kings sweet Hawaiian Bun
* Smoked Turkey
* Havarti Cheese
* Avocado
* Cayenne Pepper
* Dorothy Lynch Sauce

Assembly:
Straight forward assmebly w/ the only specifications being the buns are toasted and that the sauce dresses the entire sandwich as opposed to being spread into bun.

10. Hekate:

Ingredients:
* Ribeye
* Kaiser Roll
* Sauteed Mushrooms
* Provolone Cheese
* Chili Sauce
* Haydari

Assembly:

Straight forward assembly with only specifications being the ribeye is thin sliced, bread is toasted, and the haydari is used as a dipping sauce for the sandwich and not directly applied in assembly.
 
Deciding between Moe and spy

I think peach and peach chutney is overly peach
I also think Yolk and Maple syrup is too much

Weirdly I kinda wish both/either had chosen some form of cocoa. I,d take Moe's sub the chutney for Mole and Spy's sub the syrup for dark chocolate shavings.

Still I think these are the best samiches. Hmm, may have to make em to decide.
 
♪alt13 said:
Deciding between Moe and spy

I think peach and peach chutney is overly peach
I also think Yolk and Maple syrup is too much

Weirdly I kinda wish both/either had chosen some form of cocoa. I,d take Moe's sub the chutney for Mole and Spy's sub the syrup for dark chocolate shavings.

Still I think these are the best samiches. Hmm, may have to make em to decide.
Click to expand...

I would have Moe in the top 3 but I just hate ham, especially if it's thick sliced.
 
Moe: I've had ham and cheese in a pretzel before. Quite good. The peach is an interesting touch. If personally remove the lettuce before eating, as I think it'd be a weird combination with the peach. 7/10

Gandalfe: A standard thick cut pastrami sandwich. I'm not a huge fan of pastrami, but I'd still happily eat that sandwich. 6/10

Cy: I'm sketch on the fast food sauce and pimento cheese. Otherwise, sounds like a delicious, if heavy, sandwich. 7/10

Spycam: The maple syrup with runny egg is a gross combination. I'd ask for my egg scrambled. I've never had Kobe beef. I'm going to assume that I have to get the sandwich as is. High quality, but a bit sketchy. 5/10

WC; Just your everyday Rueben. I think the choice if bread is interesting. I like ruebens, but I don't love them. 6/10

Rubashov: Don't know what roo meat tastes like. I'm going to assume it's like beef. Pretty good sandwich. A bit weird, but I'd try.

Thee: A soggy mess, and I don't do BBQ sauce. Don't know what Apple smoked pork chunks is. Would pass. 2/10

Wes: My only concern is how the sourdough goes with the fig jam. Still, I find it mouth-watering. 8.5/10

8: A fancy turkey and avocado sandwich. I like. Would certainly eat. But nothing mind blowing. 7/10

Hekate: That's an interesting one. A Mediterranean Philly. Very intriguing. 7.5/10

Wes, Hekate, Moe.
 
Gandalfe
 
Rubashov
Move
Gandalf

I would not order any of the other trashwiches. WTF wrong with ppl like Cy, WC an Wes? Surprised none of ya dint draft boiled ******* with dog**** spread on panetta than go on yer prototypical hipster kicks bout how nobody got any class er imagination round here.
 
Most of these sandwiches have a fatal flaw for me.

Peach chutney, nope.

Maple Syrup, nope.

Fig jam, nope.

Waffles, nope.

Baked deans, eh.

Iceberg lettuce, meh.

Avocado, bleh.

Leaves me with my top 3

Hekate, Gandalfe, White Chocolate.
 
Wes asked me to list his votes. They are:

#1 - gandalfe
#2 - 8
#3 - Thee


These could maybe be used as a tiebreaker if needed.
 
Saint Cy of JFC said:
People ask the dumbest questions.
Click to expand...

I've said it before...

g4q9a75.jpg
 
Yeah if we could take things of or substitute I would take the waffles, pimento cheese, nasty chick-fil-a sauce and fried green tomatoes off Cy's sandwich and make one that actually would taste good. Or just eat the fried chicken and put the jalapenos on some nachos or something. But that is against the rules so we have to take the crappy as is.
 
1. Moevillini:
I'd like to try this if someone would make it for me :)

Ingredients:
* Pretzel bun (very lightly toasted)
* Smoked Gouda cheese
* Ham sliced off the bone (or your favorite deli ham, thick sliced)
* Grilled Peach (peel if using fresh, use half a peach or cut into slices)
* Peach Chutney (condiment)
* Butter Lettuce

2. Gandalfe:
Pastrami sandwich on marble rye - sounds decent, though I'd probably take off the pickle chips and eat them separately

3. Saint Cy of JFC:
too much fried stuff for me

4. Spycam1:
has egg - not for me

5.White Chocolate:
I generally like Reubens but order them without the dressing - so it sounds good but w/o the pickle and dressing

6.Rubashov:
not sure about the kangaroo loin, but I guess I'd give it a try
Ingredients:
* Ciabatta Roll w/ Olives (toasted)
* Kangaroo Loin
* d'Affinois Cheese
* Garlic and Mustard Mayo
* Red Onions
* Iceberg Lettuce


7.TheeJazzFan:
seems too heavy for my taste, individual ingredients all good though - though perhaps too much heat with spicy BBQ sauce plus jalepeno peppers

8. Wes Mantooth:
has egg - no go for me


9. 8:
not sure about the Dorothy Lynch sauce, but it sounds decent

Ingredients:
* Kings sweet Hawaiian Bun
* Smoked Turkey
* Havarti Cheese
* Avocado
* Cayenne Pepper
* Dorothy Lynch Sauce


10. Hekate:
the haydari sauce is a no-go for me, and not a big fan of mushrooms either - sounds OK otherwise


some of these sound good but perhaps a little too familiar and not really something I'd be overly curious to try
so I think I'd like to try my own sandwich first - the ingredients and combination sound interesting - then Rubashov in second (intriguing) and my third place vote is "8" - I like avocado on sandwiches and I can probably scrape off the sauce if I don't like it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top