UPDATE: The last of Us. Play it. Instant classic, personal top 5 all time. didn't even expect to like it since i hate zombie/horror/survival games. mind = blown. Dragons Dogma, no idea what i was getting into, bought it based on AP's review. Loved the hell out of it. As a hardcore RPG fan I will say it was better than Skyrim. Def one of the best console RPG's this gen. Just dove into the Mass effect trilogy on ps3. about 20 hours deep into #1 and loving it. showing it's age, but still a stellar game so far.
First, glad you liked
Dragon's Dogma. Hopefully you got the re-release with the extra content? Anyway, it definitely had some flaws, like an unwieldy menu system (I get that they wanted item burden for each character, but in the end having four different inventories for four different characters is just annoying) and broken difficulty at high levels (except for the bonus content, nothing is challenging after a certain points), not to mention unbalanced classes (the warrior kinda blows, while the assassin dominates), but none of it was game-breaking, and the positives all far outweighed any negatives. Capcom has said they'll be making a sequel, and if they fix a few of these small issues then that sequel really stands to make some noise. And yeah, I really think it is indeed better than
Skyrim, largely because Bethesda's actual gameplay and combat mechanics bore me to tears. There's very little difference in gameplay between
Skyrim and
Oblivion, and I had played way too much
Oblivion already to be interested in playing basically the same game again five years later. I did pick it up at below half price but probably only played about four hours or so before I gave it up as a bad job. I'll take
Dragon's Dogma any day, thanks.
As for
Mass Effect, yeah, I played through the first one like five times. Loved it to death. I wasn't as crazy about the second one even though the shooting mechanics were better. For one, the RPG elements were less deep, they added limited ammo (I was a fan of the infinite bullets myself), it has no Mako (people were divided on this, but I loved driving around in that thing), and the story suffered from middle installment syndrome -- nothing much actually happened IMO. You pretty much spend the whole game collecting your crew and then there's a final mission and the game is done. As for the third one, I haven't played it, only because I never got around to re-playing the second one, which I want to do because I badly screwed something up the first time around that will carry through to the last game.
Last of Us I've actually stayed away from despite the rave reviews, reason being that I don't like the
Uncharted games. They just seemed like cheesy Hollywood action movies in video game form (very linear), and the combat mechanics weren't particularly impressive. I'm fairly certain I would like
Last of Us better, but I'm still not interested enough to buy it at full price. Maybe I'll get a black Friday deal on it or something.