Chad Feldheimer
Well-Known Member
Tim Tebow's performance on Sunday shouldn't surprise anyone. Historically, Christians have done poorly against Lions
NFL Talk
- Thread starter KatieMCR
- Start date
Brown Notes
Well-Known Member
Katie-
I watched the game. I do not think you have a real QB. I do like your front 7 it is as good as any in the league.
IMO The 9ers need to find out if Kaep is a QB and soon. Gore is not going to be that good in 4 years.
Cheers, and good luck.
I watched the game. I do not think you have a real QB. I do like your front 7 it is as good as any in the league.
IMO The 9ers need to find out if Kaep is a QB and soon. Gore is not going to be that good in 4 years.
Cheers, and good luck.
fatchipper
Well-Known Member
Don't know why but I lol'd
You didn't believe in him before this game? I had him ranked 2/3 (Barkley/Jones).
I made an arguement earlier that I would consider Barkley and Blackman (WR) over just Luck
Gyp Rosetti
Banned
Have me on ignore? Seems about right for anyone who's a drama queen.
Just making sure this is seen.
Gyp Rosetti
Banned
Are you saying I'm being one?
You are, but catratcho is right.
Gyp Rosetti
Banned
I'm glad you like my work.
//r00t 4 Jazz
Well-Known Member
Personally I still think Luck with his pedigree (similar to Manning) would have to be rated higher but personally and my opinion means nothing but after those 3 players I think the QB from AU Foles is better (right now) then Jones at OU and there's still the combine and other draft prep that could change a lot but I think he'd be the 3rd QB I'd take after Luck and Barkley.
If you have a QB like Luck (if he is really the next Manning) then it doesn't really matter who your receivers are. Take Luck, fortify your offensive line and get some receivers who can specialize in things (deep threats and possession receivers).
Gyp Rosetti
Banned
This.
If you're the Colts specifically, draft Luck and try to trade Manning. You could probably get a couple 1sts for him if he appears back to health.
Trading Manning would be stupid. He has been everything to that franchise. Keep him, let him play another year if his health permits. If it doesn't, have him restructure his contract to have him on board as a mentor to Luck.
a la Rodgers and Favre.
candrew
Well-Known Member
Won't work. Everybody loses. It wouldn't be fair to Manning and Luck is not going to want to ease into any QB situation while Manning plays out his contract.
The Favre/Rodgers situation is completely different. Favre wasn't coming off a major injury and Rodgers was nowhere near a big of a name as Luck coming out of college. Luck is giong to walk away with the Heisman this year and is considered the most NFL-ready QBs to come out of college in years.
Luck doesn't have that kind of ego, and I don't think Manning is going to play his career out like Favre. I think Manning has one more year left in him, if any at all. I'm also sure that Manning wants to end his career with the Colts and the Colts want Manning to end his career there.
fatchipper
Well-Known Member
That's why the Colts should trade the first pick (if they get it) and draft either Barkley or Jones, then let them learn under Manning for a couple years.
Wait, you are suggesting that they shouldn't draft Luck because he is too good to be a backup for a year? This makes no sense. Get the best player available.