What's new

Jazz and Knicks discussing Donovan Mitchell trade per Shams Charania and Tony Jones

I like Kispert as a prospect but you are greatly overvaluing him. Players like him come along every draft and most of the time it is late lottery or outside the lottery.
There are not 6'7 players with league average athleticism, a quick shot, not bad on defense, and the potential to be a 40%+ 3pt shooter in every draft.

Post ASB he was shooting 39% on 6 attempts per game as a rookie. The dude is going to be lethal.


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZKtCQIE_rQ
 
I'd be all about Kispert. I think he's Wally Szczerbiak in a few seasons. Perfect type of player for our trajectory. Won't help us win now, but in a few years, should be a key role player with a rebuilt core + would have FRP+ trade value to a contender if we're still floundering.
 
His ceiling is Joe Harris... he ain't there yet. And yes there are guys at his level in every draft outside the lottery. Not the same archetype of player but at his level. His player type is valuable but 3 and D types like Grimes are more valuable imo even if the 3 part of the equation isn't quite as good.

Joe Harris is very good. He's also like a 5th starter on a championship quality team. We can buy that level of player in FA and have done so with Bogey. Give me the mystery box even though I know it likely is a lesser player than Kispert.
He's also far ahead of Harris in terms of career trajectory and is a better overall athlete.

Of course progression isnt linear and I wouldn't bet on Kispert having those two absolutely nutty shooting seasons Harris had, but I do expect him to be in the 40% range much of his career.
 
There are not 6'7 players with league average athleticism, a quick shot, not bad on defense, and the potential to be a 40%+ 3pt shooter in every draft.

Post ASB he was shooting 39% on 6 attempts per game as a rookie. The dude is going to be lethal.


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZKtCQIE_rQ

If you keep piling on qualifiers it gets real hard to discuss. There are players every year that are drafted outside the lotto that are on or above his level with regards to helping teams win games.
 
He's also far ahead of Harris in terms of career trajectory and is a better overall athlete.

Of course progression isnt linear and I wouldn't bet on Kispert having those two absolutely nutty shooting seasons Harris had, but I do expect him to be in the 40% range much of his career.
I mean if Harris suffered a terrible injury to start his career so it’s pretty tough to compare them.
 
Again, greatly underrating Kispert. You cant just find a Kispert in every draft, especially outside the lottery.

Being like "Lol he's just Joe Harris"

Joe Harris is ****ing incredible.

The Knicks/Wolves picks arent leading to stars unless you use them in trades.
I think you’re massively underrating unprotected picks 4/5/6/7 years in the future from two of the worst franchises in the last 20+ years.
 
But if it is the Wiz - we need a **** ton of picks. IMO, at least 3 firsts + 3 swaps, given that we can't get any 2023 assets from them.
Problem is because of the pick they owe to the Knicks they can’t trade any first round picks besides their 2028 1st.
 
If you keep piling on qualifiers it gets real hard to discuss. There are players every year that are drafted outside the lotto that are on or above his level with regards to helping teams win games.
Qualifiers are what makes players and what makes Kispert a good prospect. He's got a combination of size, shooting, and athleticism that isnt common.
 
I think you’re massively underrating unprotected picks 4/5/7 years in the future from two of the worst franchises in the last 20+ years.
When you are giving those franchises great players that kind of changes things.

Donovan in the NYK market is going to be good. He's going to attract another star. Leon Rose has proven himself as a capable GM who can draft well in the later rounds.

In 2027 they are going to have prime Donovan Mitchell and another star.


*and JFC I know anything can happen"

And like I said, I'd rather have that stuff to and I dont mind waiting. But it might never be there. And if we do get it, I would strongly advocate to actively shopping those picks in the coming years. I would not want to still have the 27/29 Knicks picks after the 2025 NBA season.
 
When you are giving those franchises great players that kind of changes things.

Donovan in the NYK market is going to be good. He's going to attract another star. Leon Rose has proven himself as a capable GM who can draft well in the later rounds.

In 2027 they are going to have prime Donovan Mitchell and another star.


*and JFC I know anything can happen"

And like I said, I'd rather have that stuff to and I dont mind waiting. But it might never be there. And if we do get it, I would strongly advocate to actively shopping those picks in the coming years. I would not want to still have the 27/29 Knicks picks after the 2025 NBA season.

Yeah, that seems a lot more plausible than them being a perennial play-in team with no assets, cap space or picks to improve and Donovan walks in the summer of 2025.
 
The Wizards package is more realistic if they could remove the protections on their 2023 1st they owe the Knicks to be able to give us more picks.

Problem with that is I’m not sure why the Knicks do that knowing they’re getting Donovan and the pick will be worse this year than holding onto it for a couple years and getting a potential better pick.
 
Problem is because of the pick they owe to the Knicks they can’t trade any first round picks besides their 2028 1st.
Interesting. Didn't realize that.

I'm still all about the Knicks. The draft capital there is just unbeatable, plus we know they're a garbage franchise.

Stephen A blew his wad today pleading for the trade to happen. Let's hope pressure/momentum is mounting.
 
Qualifiers are what makes players and what makes Kispert a good prospect. He's got a combination of size, shooting, and athleticism that isnt common.
He’s gonna be a Joe Harris type on the top end. He isn’t some guy with an amazing upside. He won’t play with the ball in his hand and doesn’t do anything meaningful with his “athleticism”. I’d much rather have Grimes than Kispert and he was taken in the same draft after him.

He isn’t a dime a dozen… but you give me two middle to late firsts and I think I can find something on his level that has potential to be more.
 
Stephen A said the Knicks should do Barrett + 4 1sts. Sign me up.
This is a classic thing for a Talking Head to say, as it completely glosses over the fact that the value of "4 firsts" can range wildly depending on which picks, and which protections. I don't think anyone here would sign up for Barrett + 4 heavily protected firsts. I never get why someone in the room doesn't ask a simple follow up question to the Talking Head in this scenario
 
This is a classic thing for a Talking Head to say, as it completely glosses over the fact that the value of "4 firsts" can range wildly depending on which picks, and which protections. I don't think anyone here would sign up for Barrett + 4 heavily protected firsts. I never get why someone in the room doesn't ask a simple follow up question to the Talking Head in this scenario

He said the Knicks are willing to give up 2-3 unprotected picks of their own but we want 4. The middle ground of a Barrett deal is likely 3 unprotected 1sts plus a protected 1st. I would love to get either the 2023 Dallas 1st or 2025 Milwaukee 1st.
 
He said the Knicks are willing to give up 2-3 unprotected picks of their own but we want 4. The middle ground of a Barrett deal is likely 3 unprotected 1sts plus a protected 1st. I would love to get either the 2023 Dallas 1st or 2025 Milwaukee 1st.
I'd take that deal... assuming I can settle with RJ for something less than the full version of a max extension. Say 5/150 instead of 5/188 or whatever it is.
 
Back
Top