All the best people...
Senate Republicans seem determined to elevate Donald Trump’s nominee to one of the most powerful positions in government despite more reporting around his alleged rampant abuse of women and alcohol.
Having declined to take seriously their obligation to investigate reports of his unfitness, Republicans on the committee are now refusing to credit named witnesses who are offering them credible information by taking the position that
everything negative disclosed about their man is by definition a lie.
Last week at his confirmation hearing, Hegseth stated under oath that every single allegation of misconduct was an “
anonymous smear.” One of those “anonymous smears” came from his own mother. And now Danielle Diettrich Hegseth, his former sister-in-law, “submitted a sworn statement to senators on Tuesday that accused Mr. Hegseth … of being so ‘abusive’ toward his second wife that she once hid in a closet from him and had a safe word to call for help if she needed to get away from him.” Diettrich Hegseth says she spoke with FBI agents during Hegseth’s background investigation, but her
information didn’t make its way into the report received on the Hill.
According to the Times, the former wife of Hegseth’s brother
filed this affidavit describing the future head of the Pentagon as having exhibited “erratic and aggressive” behavior that caused his then-wife to fear for her safety. That document, reviewed by the Armed Services Committee and the Times, contains yet more allegations that Hegseth “frequently drank to excess both in public and private, including on one occasion … when he was wearing his military uniform.” It further alleged that his second wife hid from him in her closet, and that he believed women should not work or
be allowed to vote.
Not one thing about these new allegations is surprising.
The New Yorker,
the New York Times, and
other media outlets have reported consistently and broadly about Hegseth’s alcoholism and mistreatment of women, as well as his revanchist views about Muslims and
frequent, public blackout drinking. There is also an allegation of sexual assault that was never charged but was reported and investigated, around which both parties have signed a nondisclosure agreement. What is, frankly, remarkable about Diettrich Hegseth’s new allegations is that she has affixed her name to them, and that they are in the possession of the FBI and the Senate. All of this would have, in a saner time, ended the nominee’s chances at confirmation.
H
is ex-wife Samantha allegedly told the FBI that “He drinks more often than he doesn’t.”
But what is even more staggering is that in the face of this new information, the decision has been taken by Senate Republicans to
discredit it, ignore it, and to charge ahead with a confirmation in spite of it.
Let us be clear.
Yet again.
Senate confirmation hearings are not criminal trials. This is, fundamentally, a job interview to determine a nominee’s fitness for office. There is no “
American presumption of innocence,” and there is no standard of proof that shifts a legal burden to the accuser to prove her claims. These confirmation hearings are systems created, at least in theory, to test facts and allegations and to ask questions about those allegations. The hearings, put simply, are meant to be directed at learning the truth. Yet despite the U.S. Senate’s awesome power to amass evidence, call witnesses, test allegations, and create a record, the Republicans of the Armed Services Committee have elected to dismiss every part of the new reporting as false. Senate Republicans are ignoring red-flag indicators and will not be able to profess surprise if more surfaces or the behaviors continue once Hegseth is in office.
If Republican senators were committed to fulfilling their obligation to advise and consent to President Trump’s nominees, they would want to know the truth; indeed they would insist upon it. At a minimum, it would be of interest to Republican members of the Armed Services Committee that the man who has been nominated to run the Defense Department is a known abuser of alcohol who is frequently abusive and threatening toward women. It increasingly appears that the campaign promise to “
protect all women” can only be achieved by silencing them first.