What's new

Gun Control

Aside from my misuse of "my". If I was a new York resident I am not on a list and could not buy a weapon from a private owner. If I lived in Colorado I would not be able to have the clips I already own...

What stops you from getting on the list in New York?

Don't bother with a clip size not being a 2nd amendment issue arguement. That is a non starter between us. You claim it is not and I claim it is.

My claim is that I can't see any reason your claim is valid. If you can find a way to support your claim, I'll reconsider.
 
What stops you from getting on the list in New York?



My claim is that I can't see any reason your claim is valid. If you can find a way to support your claim, I'll reconsider.

Sorry, "not" should not be there in reference to New York.

As for you reconsidering it. To be honest I am not really conserned if you do or not. I have those rights, see them as rights and will not give them up.
 
People are evil. As long as people are evil (and they always will be), then no matter what laws we have, crime will still happen. It would be nice if all these politicians would stop politicizing the Newtown shooting though. They don't care about those families, they just want to pass their laws that won't do anything but make people feel better.
 
Don't get this argument. You got something to hide?

Yes, that I have a gun.

If I use it responsibly, why does anyone need to know that I have one?

Regarding all the recent suggestions, they are a knee jerk reaction to Sandy Hook. Guess what? None the recent suggestion would have prevented Sandy Hook so what's the point?
 
When this thread started I expected some new gun regulations to pass. Luckily that hasn't happened.

I just heard an interview on NPR with Senator Coburn of Oklahoma. He stated flatly that most sales at gun shows are private sales, not subject to background checks under current law. He is proposing a law where potential buyers must prove they are not on the nix list to potential sellers.
 
I just heard an interview on NPR with Senator Coburn of Oklahoma. He stated flatly that most sales at gun shows are private sales, not subject to background checks under current law. He is proposing a law where potential buyers must prove they are not on the nix list to potential sellers.

I have no idea how guns shows are in OK, but here in Utahr, that just isn't the case.

Aside from gun shows; There are many private sellers (internet, etc.) that require a CCW (which requires a thorough background check by the Utah BCI) to make a transaction. This is a smart move, IMO.
 
People are evil. As long as people are evil (and they always will be), then no matter what laws we have, crime will still happen. It would be nice if all these politicians would stop politicizing the Newtown shooting though. They don't care about those families, they just want to pass their laws that won't do anything but make people feel better.

won't even do that.

it is an irrational appeasement of an ignorant mob, which said ignorant mob will go on demanding more and more appeasement based on their own "superior values". They are themselves lawless and will recognize no boundaries to their insatiable desire to impose their "feel good impulses" randomly on anyone who seems somehow out of step with their views of how everyone should be. This is the antithesis of individual rights, and the epitome of mob rule.
 
In the absence of an incipient world government with stated principles and intent to disarm the general population while retaining police arms and military arms negotiated by its unelected fascist directorate, I might see how a free society could regulate personal weapons to achieve some level of general "comfort" without excessive accidental and criminal misuse of weapons. But unwinding History back to the roots of human existence is a successive demonstration that it's not just guns, but tomahawks, crossbows, spears, clubs, and even rocks. . . . every sort of tool that ever gave one man a "leg up" in a fight. . . . . People will resort to force when a government loses authority or respect, or when any force is arrayed against them, individually or collectively. And it is intuitively obvious that every person has an equal right to life, and hence an equal right to weapons. . . . . unless you really just believe some people should be "superior" to others . . . . .

The one thing the UN stated objective does is remove, absolutely, the right of human beings to contest state force.

This observation is hard to understand next to the statement I made above, except in the fact that tyrants often find mobs useful tools/fools. So you have to go to the roots of the controversy, and look for any signs that someone is acting to incite a public outcry or issue in a way that is producing some kind of "mob" mentality.

In this context, I look at some of the posters in this forum who started out with polarizing comments bordering on hate or calling for unlawful harm/retribution, as being "useful idiots" more than reasoned, responsible people. Some right-wingnuts deal with things just as ignorantly and just as stupidly.. .. . . . but the fact that I challenge anyone to refute is the fact of today's very influential and very wealthy folks ( and specifically those who are all on board with the UN stated objective) being big pushers for new gun legislation at this time.
 
https://www.kwch.com/news/local-news/homeowner-shoots-suspect-during-attempted-breakin/29990518

SEDGWICK COUNTY, Kan. -
A Sedgwick County man shoots a person he says was breaking into his home Sunday morning.

The Sheriff's Department says Dudley reported shooting and chasing a man who was trying to break into his house. Investigators are still trying to piece together what all happened.

Sedgwick County dispatchers tell Eyewitness News the homeowner grabbed his gun to defend his family when he thought he heard someone breaking into the house. He told us, it's not something you're ever prepared for.

Even hours later, he was still worried about his family, not wanting Eyewitness News to show any close-up shots of his home, inside or out, or any other members of his family. And he only wants us to call him Mr. Dudley.

"We were awakened early this morning by the sound of our home alarm going off," said Dudley. "And that was followed by the sound of breaking glass. I went to investigate the noise and found an intruder breaking and entering my home."

That's when Dudley says he fired at the suspect, hitting him. The believed burglar, Dudley says, ran away.

"I was heading to church when I ran across several officers on the road," said his neighbor, Dave Duncan.

"We noticed all the police cars and the ambulance, and so forth," added another neighbor, Robert Christians.

The first they knew about what had happened was when the law arrived.

"It's scary. who knows," said Duncan.

"It is when you see the police here," agreed Christians about the fear.

Investigators say they found the alleged burglar a short distance away, walking, with a gunshot wound.

"I would probably have treated them the same way," said Christians.

Duncan says he's known the Dudley family for years.

"We have worked together a lot on different things. When winter time flies and the snow flies, we're all together on clearing the snow, whatever. Good neighbors to have," Duncan said.

Everyone in the neighborhood says they can't believe this happened in their community.

When asked if this was something he'd prepared for, Mr. Dudley answered, "No, ma'am. Absolutely not. Can't say that I was prepared for it. I don't know how you prepare for that."

But Christians says he has been worried more about safety lately.

"It seems there's much more lawlessness around, more burglaries, more robberies, worse than it was just a few years ago," he explained. "We make sure our doors are locked at night."

Increased security is something Dudley is more aware of now, too.

Two adults and three children were at the house at the time of the break-in and shooting. None were hurt.

"We're thankful that everyone is safe," Dudley said.

The suspect was taken to an area hospital to be treated for his gunshot wound. Once released, he was arrested on aggravated burglary charges.
 
https://www.al.com/news/montgomery/index.ssf/2014/12/faulkner_university_football_p.html

MONTGOMERY, Alabama -- Montgomery police have charged three Faulkner University students in the Wednesday night shooting death of football player Ryan Brooks.

Police say Brooks, 19, of Chelsea was shot by a homeowner in the 5900 block of Woodmere Boulevard when he and three other students attempted to break into a residence to commit a robbery.

The homeowner shot Brooks in self-defense, according to police.

Montgomery police say those Faulkner University students involved in the home invasion robbery have been charged with murder.

They are: Marshall Wall, 19, Ronnie Williams 19, both of Loxley, and Tabias Russell, 19, of Alexander City. They are being held in the Montgomery County Detention Facility on $75,000 bond.

Montgomery police found Brooks dead of a gunshot wound at around 7:38 p.m.

Brooks, Williams and Russell are members Faulkner's junior varsity football team. Wall is a member of the school's soccer team.

"In its 72-year history, Faulkner University has never had a shooting involving a student," university President Billy D. Hilyer said, during an afternoon press conference. "The safety and well-being of our students is paramount at this university."

Faulkner Chief of Police Tony Dean said Brooks and the three students charged all lived on campus.

"There is no indication this (homicide) is an overflow of something that occurred on campus," he said.

University officials didn't speak about the circumstances during the shooting death at the press conference, but did confirm that three students had been charged.

Dean said he was notified by Montgomery police just moments after the shooting occurred that they believed it involved a Faulkner student.

The Faulkner campus wasn't placed on lockdown Wednesday evening, he said, but extra officers were called in in case the investigation lead back to campus.

Rumors spread on social media that Brooks' death stemmed from a fraternity hazing.

Faulkner's Vice President of Student Services Jean-Noel Thompson said there is no evidence to support those rumors.

He said he has spoken with one of Brooks' parents.

Faulkner is a christian university with 2,400 students attending its Montgomery campus. About 700 of those students live on campus.
 
...You stated before that you think there should be an anti-gun propaganda campaign much like the anti-smoking campaign. To me that says you already see guns much like many people see cigarettes. Just a negative part of the world we live in that should be minimized and mitigated to do the least harm. I'm not on board with that. Our goals are different. There is no room for a compromise between your view and mine....


So here it is folks, the solution to our gun problems.

#1 Registration of all firearms

#2 Licensing of all firearms owners, requiring periodic training and renewal.

#3 Tight control of ammo sales, including a requirement to account for ammo on hand and all ammo spent. Limits on the amount of ammo allowed per household.

#4 Requirement to have all guns secured. Penalties and loss of firearms rights if guns fall into the wrong hands and/or stolen guns are not promptly reported.

#5 Insane penalties for any misuse of guns, much like our current penalties for drug possession.

#6 Public opinion campaign to create a common notion that guns are bad. Regulations and red tape so thick it makes most shooting sports so difficult to participate in that they become unpopular and die out.

#7 Making images of guns so offensive (so that showing a gun in any positive light is like saying the N word in public) that they no longer appear in TV shows, movies or video games.

I'm of the opinion that those are what is required to "cure" our current gun problem. Anything short and you aren't going to accomplish much. That's what us pro gun folks all realize and why we are steering clear of any compromise that takes us near the slippery slope that leads to what I've said. I give the leaders of the anti-gun movement credit for knowing the exact same thing, which is why I question their motives and why I'm suspicious over obviously ineffective proposals for gun regulation.

Too many people seem to be far too trigger-happy and far too irresponsible in the care and use of the guns they own. But hopefully natural selection will take care of that problem.

So yeah, the problem will eventually solve itself!

In the meantime, let's all speak with as much hyperbole as we can muster.
(see what I did there?)
 
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-nordstrom-gun-met-20141205-story.html

Woman who bought handgun is charged with false report in Nordstrom shooting...

Authorities said a Skokie woman who had once owned the gun used in the brazen murder-suicide at the Nordstrom store off Michigan Avenue last week was charged Friday night with disorderly conduct after filing a false police report.

Nina Dones, 23, falsely reported in September that the .45-caliber semi-automatic handgun had been stolen from her Skokie apartment, according to law enforcement sources.

Police have said that Marcus Dee used the gun to fatally shoot his ex-girlfriend before turning the weapon on himself as shoppers ran for safety on Black Friday, one of the busiest shopping days of the year....

The sources said a former or current boyfriend of Dones' was an acquaintance of Dee's.

Dones is scheduled to appear for a bond hearing Saturday at the Leighton Criminal Court Building, said Sally Daly, a spokeswoman for the Cook County state's attorney's office. She confirmed that Dones had been charged with one count of disorderly conduct, a felony...

Investigators traced the weapon to Dones through her purchase of the gun in 2013 at GAT Guns, a 45,000-square-foot store and indoor range in northwest suburban East Dundee, the source said.

Nordstrom was crowded with holiday shoppers at about 8:30 p.m. on Nov. 28 when Dee confronted his ex-girlfriend, Nadia Ezaldein, a seasonal employee at the store. As Ezaldein walked away, Dee, 31, shot her in the head before shooting himself in the head, authorities said.

Family members have said Dee physically abused Ezaldein throughout their 16-month relationship. She broke up with Dee last December after he put a gun in her mouth, they said.

Copyright © 2014, Chicago Tribune

I'm not sure how anything here proves she filed a false report of a stolen gun, and I'm not sure why the charge for that would be disorderly conduct, but what do I know? Not much, apparently.

But I am glad that sufficient records existed to trace the gun's ownership.
 
Too many people seem to be far too trigger-happy and far too irresponsible in the care and use of the guns they own. But hopefully natural selection will take care of that problem.

So yeah, the problem will eventually solve itself!

In the meantime, let's all speak with as much hyperbole as we can muster.
(see what I did there?)

The problem with Gameface is that he wasn't doing hyperbole. To be "hyperbole" the idea has to be a statement in excess of fact, not an understatement.

The fact is, most of us are in a state of comparative ignorance about agendas or political motives, and we think we can just be reasonable and have sensible lives of our choosing. Political agendas by definition are an attempt to stampede the human herd into unreasonable fears and acceptance of specific political power grabs.

hyperbole usually doesn't include qualifiers in generalities like "sometimes" or "often" nor quantifiers like "some" or "most". Even your "hyperbole" has qualifiers, quantifiers and such. . . . "too many", "too. . . . happy", "too irresponsible".

You need more practice, and an expert teacher. I'm the ultimate over-qualified Hyperbole Czar. I give lessons frequently.
 
Last edited:
Dictators and other thieves don't want you to have guns while they're asserting possession of your stuff or doing away with your life. (this is a generality. . . . do you know any exceptions to the rule?)

Political idealists are dupes Dictators love, and fools thieves look for. (unsupported by data, and possibly wrong. . . a statement suspicious of hyperbole. . . . but show me one dictator, or one thief, who has ever made a campaign in support of gun rights as a human right)

Darkside Cops plan their arrests and other operations with an eye to achieving "kills" on the job, in order to cause civil turmoil, so obviously we need to hire rent-a-mob protesters hand-picked by the same political operatives who organize cells of "darkside cops". The objective is to disarm the public, and eventually declare martial law and suspend elections. The political pluses of such tactics are that politicians achieve more power over the folks, who will vote for and accept and obey more government authority over life on the streets.

The politicians can then vote themselves more pay and perks, and their bureaucratic minions can hire more "help" and get bigger trucks, and personal arsenals for "self-protection". The babes will adoringly follow, and life wil be plush and lush.

Sometimes I wish I could actually do hyperbole when talking about the evils of our government.
 
https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/loc...s-Suspect-Who-Tried-to-Rob-Him-284642891.html

Off-Duty San Francisco Police Officer Shoots Man Who Tried to Rob Him: Police
ByBay City News

An attempted robbery suspect was taken to a hospital after being shot by an off-duty police officer in San Francisco's Lower Nob Hill neighborhood.
Wednesday, Dec 3, 2014 • Updated at 7:13 PM PST

An attempted robbery suspect was shot by an off-duty San Francisco police officer in the city's Lower Nob Hill neighborhood Wednesday morning, a police spokeswoman said.
According to San Francisco police Sgt. Monica MacDonald, police received reports shortly before 6 a.m. of gunshots heard in the area of Leavenworth and Pine streets.
Fla. Man Stuffs Beef Tongue in Pants at Walmart
Officers responded to the area but were unable to find anything out of the ordinary, MacDonald said. She said based on the preliminary police investigation, it appears someone was trying to break into a car by smashing a window with a wooden stick, possibly a chair leg.
A passerby saw the male suspect and confronted him. The suspect then struck the passerby with the wooden object and robbed him, MacDonald said.
Top News Photos of the Week[NATL] Top News Photos of the Week
The victim didn't initially report the incident and went home to clean himself up and get ready for work, according to the sergeant.
The same passerby was then walking to work when he saw an altercation inside Another Café, a coffee shop at Leavenworth and Pine. The same suspect allegedly threw coffee on someone inside the coffee shop and then exited, MacDonald said.
Scarlett Johansson Marries in Secret
The suspect made his way into a nearby apartment building, where the off-duty police officer was exiting an apartment in the building and encountered him in a hallway, MacDonald said.
The suspect then tried to rob the officer, who identified himself and drew his weapon, the sergeant said. The suspect refused to comply and told the officer that he would have to have to kill him, MacDonald said. The officer holstered his handgun, and the two became engaged in a physical struggle, according to police. The officer called for backup during the fight, during which the suspect struck the officer and bit him, causing lacerations, MacDonald said.
SoCal Couple Cleared in Daughter's Death Leaves Qatar
The suspect then reached for the officer's gun, which discharged once, striking the suspect in the upper body, MacDonald said. She said blood was found all over the hallway inside the apartment building when on-duty police officers arrived.
The suspect, whose name is not yet being released, was transported to San Francisco General Hospital, according to MacDonald. She did not know his condition. She said the off-duty officer, whose name is also not immediately being released, teaches defensive tactics at the department.

Video the suspect before the shooting can be found here:
https://www.groopie.tv/watch/ln1wG
 
https://www.wafb.com/story/27558613/police-say-homeowner-shoots-man-during-break-in

BATON ROUGE, LA (WAFB) - Police said a suspected would-be burglar was shot while breaking in to a home Friday.

The Baton Rouge Police Department identified the suspected burglar as James Boyette, 36. He later died at the hospital.

Police said the shooting happened on Woodhaven Street in Baton Rouge around noon.

"He heard somebody in the back of his home," said Cpl. L'Jean McKneely with BRPD. "When he went to investigate what was going on, he saw the individual inside the house and he confronted him and shot him."

Investigators said the homeowner found Boyette in a bedroom inside the home and shot him."We definitely all look after each other, very well," said Pete Dawson, a neighbor.

"A man at home minding his own business has a right to protect himself and his family," said District Attorney Hillar Moore.

The homeowner will not be charged.
Police added Boyette had a long criminal history and had drugs on him at the time of the break-in and shooting.

"He was troubled and did have a past and that is probably what led him into breaking into that home," McKneely said.

The shooting remains under investigation.
 
Back
Top