What's new

Spartacus

I think it was good that they kept it accurate to the chronological line and concepts. If I have seen them taking this to a solid victory of the gladiators against Rome, it would get boring for me. Sometimes winning is not only killing all the other soldiers of the enemy. Sometimes, especially in the longest term, like your fellow William Wallace, death in the road of the cause affects the consequences much more than physical destruction. But most of the time, heroes die in the way of pure honor, yet no one else holds onto them anymore. Spartacus and William Wallace were the lucky ones I guess. Heroes like that will still rise and lead people to higher values of themselves than they are imprisoned in by the social structure, and only some of them will be remembered in the history books.

One of my favorite aspects of Spartacus was how twisted it was. Naevia got killed being reprimanded like a slave and completely humiliated. Crixus killed by the most detestable dweebs in the show (Tiberius). Spartacus on the verge of defeating the undefeatable speared in the back. ETC
 
One of my favorite aspects of Spartacus was how twisted it was. Naevia got killed being reprimanded like a slave and completely humiliated. Crixus killed by the most detestable dweebs in the show (Tiberius). Spartacus on the verge of defeating the undefeatable speared in the back. ETC


They did well on showing the despair of the slave revolution. I was never actually into the Naevia character too much, nor Crixus' love with her, not when she was a slave, not after she became a gladiator. Too cheesy of a character development for me. I wish Doctoré was with them until the final moments. He was badass.

One of the highlights of the show was the fight of Crixus-Thracian against the giant. And Liam McIntyre did his job great in taking over the Spartacus role. None other would do better in my opinion.

Silly as it sounds, the best fit character /actor in the series was Ashur role actor Nick Tarabay for me. As much as I hated him, he was a great fit.
 
Just watching it now on Netflix, middle of 3d season. Great show, what else to say. To bad about Whitfield, I think McIntyre was nowhere near as good as him. I think dude who plays Thor would be be better fit as replacement.
 
Ok, finally finished it. One of the best shows of all times easily. Surprisingly few historical inaccuracies did not bother me to much (For example - Crassus never had son named Tiberius, Ceasar never participated in slave war, Oenemaus was not black, Castus was not black, Gannickus was not crucified, etc). It was just hard to watch last few episodes knowing that inevitable death and defeat of revolt is coming. Again, those who did not watch it yet should start doing it ASAP.
 
Ok, finally finished it. One of the best shows of all times easily. Surprisingly few historical inaccuracies did not bother me to much (For example - Crassus never had son named Tiberius, Ceasar never participated in slave war, Oenemaus was not black, Castus was not black, Gannickus was not crucified, etc). It was just hard to watch last few episodes knowing that inevitable death and defeat of revolt is coming. Again, those who did not watch it yet should start doing it ASAP.

I vowed to not post in the GD forum since my return because I only got myself in trouble with the mods, but I think I'm good to go with this thread.

It's interesting to hear your insight considering you were apparently well-versed in the history/legend. I had heard the name, but didn't know the story, so the show as all new to me and I had no idea what was coming. It's cool you were just as entertained. Although, I've read that all documents are lost from that time, so no one really knows the full truths of people/events/etc.

Regardless, I've rewatched several episodes on netflix and unfortunately there's just no comparison between Andy and Liam. Liam did a good job, but Andy was the best. So season 1 is my favorite still despite the first couple episodes being relatively weak.

Based on sheer entertainment value, how would you rank the top 5 characters? Here's mine:

1. Batiatus
2. Spartacus
3. Ashur
4. Gannicus
5. Crassus
 
  • Like
Reactions: MVP
I

Based on sheer entertainment value, how would you rank the top 5 characters? Here's mine:

1. Batiatus
2. Spartacus
3. Ashur
4. Gannicus
5. Crassus

Yeah, Batiatus was certainly the top one. Not much to add to your list TBH, maybe Oenemaus. Not sure if Crixus role required him to be so dumb and primitive and M. Bennet did really good job portraying him that way but it was hard to like him because of those particular qualities.
 
Back
Top