LogGrad98
Well-Known Member
Contributor
20-21 Award Winner
2022 Award Winner
2023 Award Winner
2024 Award Winner
I really try to not just spam this guy's stuff, and a lot of times that's easy because I don't agree with him. But I want to make a specific point that piggybacks off what he says in this video.
The point I want to make is that the Republican party has really shot themselves in the foot by calling everything "socialism." They are pointing at broadly popular public welfare ideas and screaming like toddlers who didn't get the candy they wanted that it is socialism. They are pointing at heath care ideas that would give Americans something close to what the rest of the industrialized world has had for decades and stomping their feet, crossing their arms and calling it SOCIALISM!!! They are pointing at environmentalism and calling it SOCIALISM!!! They oppose an increase to minimum wage because... SOCIALISM!!!
They don't realize they are popularizing the concept of socialism amongst all but the oldest and most angry in our society. They are bringing up an entire generation that hears that every decent idea they see that could make the lives of average Americans better is socialism.
I mean we could have just called it welfare and handouts and made good faith arguments about why those things disincentivize hard work and innovation, but that isn't what has happened. They just call it all socialism, while lumping in many things that are in fact NOT socialism, then calling centrist capitalist Democrats extreme socialists.
Republicans have effectively changed the definition of socialism and what a socialist is to the point that many if not most young people look at the situation and consider if they are actually socialists themselves.
So thank you neocons, I'm NOT a socialist, but in order to oppose fascists I'm probably going to have to align with a coming wave of actual socialism that you have created. I mean I'm down for a better health insurance system. I don't want socialism. But I will pick socialism over fascism 10 times out of 10. So thanks.
Great post.
Realistically, socialism as it exists in the minds of the right doesn't really exist anywhere in the world. There are very few states that operate as pure socialist states. Just like we are absolutely not a pure capitalist state, and pure capitalist state just don't exist. Every developed nation that they point to to villainize socialism is somewhere on the spectrum between pure socialism and pure capitalism. And frankly the best and most stable and most effective for their populations are about right in the middle, with substantial socialist programs that provide for basic standard of living including effective medical care that then provides a very stable foundation for their capitalist systems. It's just a fact that if you provide for your most basic needs, including education, healthcare, food security, shelter, etc then it allows your society to thrive in the capitalist realm as well. So sad that we have fallen so far from our own ideals and use these specters of evil to drive a backward approach to social support systems because, for some reason that they can never articulate, it's a terrible thing for everyone to have reasonable access to healthcare. Apparently.