Tucker Carlson’s Rhetoric and White Replacement Theory

[The Thriller]

If one can't hear the whistle on that one they'll never hear it.

Perhaps. Or perhaps people just need to become more familiar with the history of this type of rhetoric? I mean I have my doubts because Tucker’s racism is pretty obvious. But maybe people really are ignorant of these dog whistles?

White Replacement Theory:
White supremacists have been using this type of rhetoric for decades. For a long time they've claimed that elites (usually Jews) are trying to replace Christian white conservatives with immigrants. Remember Donald’s very fine people in Charlottesville chanting words to the effect of “we will not be replaced?”

So they’re fearful that Immigrants with a divided allegiance to America and traditional (white) conservative and Christian values will replace whites. While it may adjust its image (sometimes it’s blacks overrunning america, sometimes it’s muslims, sometimes it’s the Spanish speaking brown horde), it’s always the same message; there are enemies coming to overrun America and white conservatives must do everything to defend America from them. If they fail, then whites will be replaced and America will be beyond rescue.

Rep King got it:

Tucker’s rhetoric has impressed KKK members:

And is gaining recognition by VDare:

White nationalist website calls Tucker Carlson’s ‘replacement’ rant ‘one of the best things Fox News has ever aired’

The Fox News host has won the praise of an officially designated hate group after appearing to endorse the racist ‘replacement’ theory

ca.finance.yahoo.com

And is being used to justify Donald Trump’s “loss”, insurrection, and Republican efforts to suppress the votes through new election laws. Between Trump’s lying about the election being stolen and Tucker’s racism, they’re creating an even more fearful and paranoid base that believes that the country is headed towards war.

The conservative movement is rejecting America

A recent essay in a prominent right-wing outlet gives an unusually clear window into the modern right’s anti-democratic worldview.

www.vox.com

 

[The Thriller]

This is written by a Republican:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/04/12/how-tucker-carlsons-racist-rhetoric-gives-new-life-trumpism/

And it’s not just a one time thing. He’s been preaching white supremacy for years. Saying that immigration makes our country poorer and dirtier is textbook white supremacy


Using such dehumanizing language was common in Nazi Germany and other mass genocides (like Rwanda). Labeling “the other” as socialist, atheist, not loyal, degenerate, immoral, etc helps white supremacists (or just anyone) justify their actions against their targets.

Origins of Neo-Nazi and White Supremacist Terms and Symbols: A Glossary - United States Holocaust Memorial Museum

The leaders of today’s Neo-Nazi and White Supremacist organizations are not Adolf Hitler, and America is not Germany, but, in order to understand their agenda, it is vital to understand the history of these code words, symbols, and ideologies.

www.ushmm.org

“Alien,” “Parasite,” “Degenerate”​

In order to make Jewish persecution publicly palatable, Nazi propagandists branded Jews as a biological threat to Germany. Government-sponsored racist propaganda was widely distributed denouncing Jews as “alien,” and “parasitic,” and responsible for Germany’s cultural, political, and economic “degeneration.”

 

[The Thriller]

A more complete rendition. Some might claim he is saying the Democrats want to make the United States less white....

Tucker Carlson: The truth about demographic change and why Democrats want it

Last week, we said something on television that the usual chorus of hyperaggressive liars is now pretending was somehow highly controversial.

www.foxnews.com

And, since the situation on the border largely involves people from a triangle of Central American countries, it may be educational to examine our own history in that region:

What Happens in El Norte

It’s hard to believe that more than four years have passed since the police shot Amílcar Pérez-López a few blocks from my house in San Francisco’s Mission District. He was an immigrant, 20

tomdispatch.com

Good post

 

[babe]

This is the kind of rhetoric that anyone with a conscience and/or a brain should choke at saying.

Used to be a "White Supremacist" would equate with a Lord Cecil Rhodes scheming to prevent "the darkies", as perhaps he would have called them, from asserting political power in the hinterlands of "civilization": or the "backwaters of society": as perhaps John Wesley Powell would have termed it..

In short, the founders of the Progressive movement. The very "woke" followers of this tradition today just won't intellectually address the place of a Sen. Byrd or a Fulbright in their tradition, or a Margaret Sanger.

The actual racists today are the "Woke Supremacists" and/or the Han 22nd Century Dynasty..... uhhhmm..... the Global Han Dynasty. I dunno, though. Maybe Xi is the puppet and maybe the Brits are still the puppet masters. The trouble with global schemes is just that it's so damn hard to know who's screwing whos.....uhhhmmmm.... except that it is always true that the ordinary citizens always get the shaft the worst.

Furthermore, it is standard training in the Marxist tradition to deploy activists on every side of an issue that is to be exploited politically. That means, when you hear Progressives piling on to accuse people of "White Supremacist" this or that, it is groups they have themselves set up, dressed in the lingo and/or garb appropriate to the genre. A sort of political pigeon, if you will, to be shot down by the Woke opposition. It's a puppet show, really.

I think there may be a few very small enclaves or lone household in the Northwest Woods who have fled there to preserve some ideal of White, but they are largely isolationists. They don't organize rallies or political groups. I've never heard of such a thing.

But all of a sudden, following Obama's lead on agitating the racial divide, which as a Marxist he is certainly woke up to do, we have "White Supremacists" everywhere the Woke Dummies look.

It's a farce.

The growing resistance to the Progressive takeover is populated with people of every stripe. It's just the fake Republicans like Romney and the fake Democrats like almost all the Dem leadership today that are on board with the agenda to transform America.

The more you push such fake narratives and fake issues, the more people you lose.

You should be ashamed of yourselves.

 

[One Brow]

I do if you make it your agenda.

No, not my agenda. The agenda of the alt-right, who know their agenda better than anyone, and say Tucker Carlson spreads it for them.

**** the alt right.

I understand you don't like the thoughts of all that they stand for.

Going back to the video, what did the Carston guy say that was white supremacy? I'm serious. Educate me.

Already done, I see.

 

[babe]

Most "Conservatives" or "Republicans" I have heard talking about these issues would be better described as believing it is "Republican Replacement Strategy" to bring in people from heavily Marxist-indoctrinated regions. They allege our "Wokesters" have groups down there with loads of cash organizing the Caravans and buying off Cartels to give them the pass. The idea here is the Dems know they need new dupes for their political base.

But the problem they face at a deeper level, on the longer term, is the number of these imported "Democrats' who are switching to Republican's.

And they're running out of dupes in Mexico or Central America. Now they're bringing them from other places too.

 

[One Brow]

Used to be a "White Supremacist" would equate with a Lord Cecil Rhodes scheming to prevent "the darkies", as perhaps he would have called them, from asserting political power in the hinterlands of "civilization": or the "backwaters of society": as perhaps John Wesley Powell would have termed it..

In short, the founders of the Progressive movement.

This is true. The founders of the progressive movement were almost as racist their opponents. Almost.

The very "woke" followers of this tradition today just won't intellectually address the place of a Sen. Byrd or a Fulbright in their tradition, or a Margaret Sanger.

This is a lie. They recognize the racism of a Byrd (and his remorse) or a Sanger, just we do for Washington or Lincoln. That doesn't mean we ject everything done by these people.

 

[One Brow]

Most "Conservatives" or "Republicans" I have heard talking about these issues would be better described as believing it is "Republican Replacement Strategy" to bring in people from heavily Marxist-indoctrinated regions.

These people are so Catholic, that if Republicans would welcome them with open arms, most would vote Republican on the abortion issue alone.

 

[babe]

No, not my agenda. The agenda of the alt-right, who know their agenda better than anyone, and say Tucker Carlson spreads it for them.


I understand you don't like the thoughts of all that they stand for.


Already done, I see.

Tucker talked about the trash, which is due to the numbers of people and the facilities. No Portapotties or trash cans. Biden and his folk are such poor planners, and unwilling to provide the necessities for these people.

But again, you should be ashamed of your dishonesty here. But it is the talking points you're handed, and you're just a loyal unthinking activist I know. Like the poor folk at guvmint camps generally doing what they're told, feeling they must because they have no credentials to decide otherwise.

This is wholesale abandonment of your brain and your conscience, bro.

The "alt righ" in your agenda does not exist except as created by the next level up in the hierarchy of agenda management. They have to create the monster in order to make it the fear gripping issue.

I have never met a white Supremacist. Tucker Carlson is not anything like that.

but no doubt, you can twist everything to fit your imagination.

Most of this kind of Republican comment is directed at stuff like homeless camps the Dems won't do anything about, the "Sanctuary" governments run by Dems who won't clean the streets or provide toilet service.

A lot of Americans decry this kind of filth, created by Dem governance.

 

[babe]

These people are so Catholic, that if Republicans would welcome them with open arms, most would vote Republican on the abortion issue alone.

I have to give you credit on this one. But Catholics who are taught Marxism in public schools. There's a pretty strong element of Marxist or Socialist at least, in the clergy ranks, so that even in Catholic schools a lot of such indoctrination takes place.

But beyond that, it's really the idea of economic opportunity that turns most of these newcomers towards more traditional American politics.

 

[babe]

Tucker talked about the trash, which is due to the numbers of people and the facilities. No Portapotties or trash cans. Biden and his folk are such poor planners, and unwilling to provide the necessities for these people.

But again, you should be ashamed of your dishonesty here. But it is the talking points you're handed, and you're just a loyal unthinking activist I know. Like the poor folk at guvmint camps generally doing what they're told, feeling they must because they have no credentials to decide otherwise.

This is wholesale abandonment of your brain and your conscience, bro.

The "alt righ" in your agenda does not exist except as created by the next level up in the hierarchy of agenda management. They have to create the monster in order to make it the fear gripping issue.

I have never met a white Supremacist. Tucker Carlson is not anything like that.

but no doubt, you can twist everything to fit your imagination.

Most of this kind of Republican comment is directed at stuff like homeless camps the Dems won't do anything about, the "Sanctuary" governments run by Dems who won't clean the streets or provide toilet service.

A lot of Americans decry this kind of filth, created by Dem governance.

Strange notion here.....

If the Dem governance decided to really help the homeless and the poor, and clean their streets, they could really make an impression on everyone.

 

[babe]

This is true. The founders of the progressive movement were almost as racist their opponents. Almost.


This is a lie. They recognize the racism of a Byrd (and his remorse) or a Sanger, just we do for Washington or Lincoln. That doesn't mean we ject everything done by these people.

Well, lie or not, I hope people will make corrections to their thinking, or their traditions, when the evidence shows the need.

 

[Archie Moses]

Already done, I see.

Seems pretty clear but I must have missed it.

As someone who is anti-white supremacy, can you please explain to me how that video promotes white supremacy?

I'm so confused.

I watched it thinking the guy was gonna say something horrible and be a hack.

I'm not sure, but maybe people are diluting what white supremacy really is.

White supremacy is bad, out dated, wrong and I condemn it to the highest degree.

Can we agree on that?

 

[Gameface]

Seems pretty clear but I must have missed it.

As someone who is anti-white supremacy, can you please explain to me how that video promotes white supremacy?

I'm so confused.

I watched it thinking the guy was gonna say something horrible and be a hack.

I'm not sure, but maybe people are diluting what white supremacy really is.

White supremacy is bad, out dated, wrong and I condemn it to the highest degree.

Can we agree on that?

I have not and have no plans to watch a Tucker Carlson video. I have no idea what he says and no interest in what he says.

So that out of the way I just want to say that I agree with you and I believe you.

 

[The Thriller]

I have not and have no plans to watch a Tucker Carlson video. I have no idea what he says and no interest in what he says.

So that out of the way I just want to say that I agree with you and I believe you.

Maybe it would’ve helped if you had watched it. But claiming that elites and Democrats are encouraging nonwhite immigration to replace conservative/Christian whites in order to change then politics in the country isn’t just a white supremacist dog whistle, but bull horn.

 

[One Brow]

Tucker talked about the trash, which is due to the numbers of people and the facilities.

He discussed the trash, and he discussed "replacement theory". The former is not tied to white supremacism, that latter is.

 

[One Brow]

Seems pretty clear but I must have missed it.

There are several posts already describing replacement theory, its history and meaning, etc. At some point repetition is pointless. You won't see what you refuse to see.

I'm not sure, but maybe people are diluting what white supremacy really is.

White supremacy is bad, out dated, wrong and I condemn it to the highest degree.

Can we agree on that?

I already agreed that you condemn it when described denotationally, but have a comfort level with the connotations.

 

[The Thriller]

 

[cowhide]

Tucker talked about the trash, which is due to the numbers of people and the facilities. No Portapotties or trash cans. Biden and his folk are such poor planners, and unwilling to provide the necessities for these people.

But again, you should be ashamed of your dishonesty here. But it is the talking points you're handed, and you're just a loyal unthinking activist I know. Like the poor folk at guvmint camps generally doing what they're told, feeling they must because they have no credentials to decide otherwise.

This is wholesale abandonment of your brain and your conscience, bro.

The "alt righ" in your agenda does not exist except as created by the next level up in the hierarchy of agenda management. They have to create the monster in order to make it the fear gripping issue.

I have never met a white Supremacist. Tucker Carlson is not anything like that.

but no doubt, you can twist everything to fit your imagination.

Most of this kind of Republican comment is directed at stuff like homeless camps the Dems won't do anything about, the "Sanctuary" governments run by Dems who won't clean the streets or provide toilet service.

A lot of Americans decry this kind of filth, created by Dem governance.

too funny. What did trump and the republicans do about the homeless. Absolutely NOTHING. Please your fake outrage about how democratic states are run while completely ignoring the fact how poor and uneducated most red states are. Lets not forget how any time of safety net the government provides is automatically deemed socialism. The fact that you are in white denial about Tucker Carson only shows how ridiculous your points are. Tucker should just wear a white hood on air so all debate whether he is or isn't racist can stop. Anyone with the slightest understanding of white supremacy in the USA would no he is.

 

[Archie Moses]

There are several posts already describing replacement theory, its history and meaning, etc. At some point repetition is pointless. You won't see what you refuse to see.


I already agreed that you condemn it when described denotationally, but have a comfort level with the connotations.

I haven't read the whole thread. I'm not sure why asking a simple question I have is pointless for you to help educate me.

Just talking about what I saw and heard.