Haha, no way an 18 yr old is dropping the amount of cash it takes to get a bottle of Aventus, so I have to think you're referring to Le Male. It's not my fave, but like I mentioned, it's one of the wife's faves, so it stays in the collection. It was way overplayed (much like AdG), but it's a decent scent.
Admittedly I had never heard of most you named

But I haven't smelled Gaultier on a person older then let's say 23. I had used it myself, but I think its way too annoying. No matter if you like it, you have to bear its presence if you're within 20 yards of the person wearing it. I also made the experience that young girls like it as it's very noticable. It smells sexy and that's attractive I guess.
Gaining a couple years I think it's the annoying kind of attractive. Like Hooters girls are attractive but in an undesirable way.