What's new
By:

Bronco Leaving BYU for...

I've been ready for a change. Bronco was the right hire at the time, and he's done a fantastic job. But, I'm sick of being stuck in mediocrity. Besides, these players already have a Bishop and Elders Quorum President, they don't need their football coach doing it as well.
 
Red Jazz Fan said:
Debatable. Yet the U has a scrub at QB. Go figure.
Click to expand...
They do? Wilson is far from Perfect, but he's not a scrub. The offense Kyle runs is ultra conservative. That's not conducive to looking good as a QB. I'd take Wilson over Hill or Mangum right now.
 
gregbroncs said:
They do? Wilson is far from Perfect, but he's not a scrub. The offense Kyle runs is ultra conservative. That's not conducive to looking good as a QB. I'd take Wilson over Hill or Mangum right now.
Click to expand...

Would you take wilson over a healthy taysom?
 
fishonjazz said:
Would you take wilson over a healthy taysom?
Click to expand...
Part of the problem with Taysom is that he is never healthy. There was a time I'd take that guy at USU over either of them but he has the same problem as Taysom. As for healthy Taysom over Healthy Wilson I think it's far closer than people want to admit. Wilson had no advantages, 4 different OC's, and a conservative coach that won't run a modern offense or even a real offense, that also moves all of the athleticism to the defensive side of the ball.
 
gregbroncs said:
Part of the problem with Taysom is that he is never healthy. There was a time I'd take that guy at USU over either of them but he has the same problem as Taysom. As for healthy Taysom over Healthy Wilson I think it's far closer than people want to admit. Wilson had no advantages, 4 different OC's, and a conservative coach that won't run a modern offense or even a real offense, that also moves all of the athleticism to the defensive side of the ball.
Click to expand...

A season of healthy taysom is guaranteed to be drafted in the nfl. Hell even always injured taysom who just missed the whole season has a chance at the nfl simply due to measurables. (Size, speed, strength, athleticism)

Do you think Wilson gets drafted even after a full healthy season in which the utes had their best year in the pac12 and reached a #3 ranking? I don't.

I think it's not close at all.
Healthy taysom is a heisman contender and surefire nfl draft pick despite playing for a team that doesn't get any heisman players or nfl guys.

Healthy wilson with his team playing their best football is nowhere near the heisman discussion and very unlikely to be drafted.

I think this is one of those agree to disagree things I guess
 
fishonjazz said:
A season of healthy taysom is guaranteed to be drafted in the nfl. Hell even always injured taysom who just missed the whole season has a chance at the nfl simply due to measurables. (Size, speed, strength, athleticism)

Do you think Wilson gets drafted even after a full healthy season in which the utes had their best year in the pac12 and reached a #3 ranking? I don't.

I think it's not close at all.
Healthy taysom is a heisman contender and surefire nfl draft pick despite playing for a team that doesn't get any heisman players or nfl guys.

Healthy wilson with his team playing their best football is nowhere near the heisman discussion and very unlikely to be drafted.

I think this is one of those agree to disagree things I guess
Click to expand...
No Taysom wouldn't be guaranteed at all. He doesn't throw the ball well enough to guarantee that.
.
No Travis won't be drafted. He may get a look as UDFA but I doubt that. I put that on coaches though, coming out of high school he was highly regarded, he wasn't developed properly and he had horrible OC/HC for a QB.
.
I think Taysom is overrated especially at passing. He an athletic freak, But as a QB I don't think he fits the NFL and there is no way he is a sure fire draft pick. He would have been in the Heisman voting but that is because of his legs more than his arm.
 
gregbroncs said:
No Taysom wouldn't be guaranteed at all. He doesn't throw the ball well enough to guarantee that.
.
No Travis won't be drafted. He may get a look as UDFA but I doubt that. I put that on coaches though, coming out of high school he was highly regarded, he wasn't developed properly and he had horrible OC/HC for a QB.
.
I think Taysom is overrated especially at passing. He an athletic freak, But as a QB I don't think he fits the NFL and there is no way he is a sure fire draft pick. He would have been in the Heisman voting but that is because of his legs more than his arm.
Click to expand...
We just aren't going to see eye to eye on this one I guess. Agree to disagree
 
Taysom was carving up nebraska in the passing game before he got hurt, dude has just as good of an arm as his legs...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top