What's new
By:

Jazz player grades so far...

str8line

str8line

Well-Known Member
Contributor
2019 Award Winner
Taking injury out of the equation.


Here's mine:

1. George Hill- A+
2. Gordon Hayward- A+
3. Rudy Gobert- A
4. Rodney Hood- A-
5. Derrick Favors- A-
6. Joel Bolomboy- A-
7. Dante Exum- B
8. Joe Johnson- B
9. Jeff Withey- B
10. Shelvin Mack- C+
11. Trey Lyles- D+


EDIT: Joe Ingles B-
 
Last edited:
str8line said:
Taking injury out of the equation.


Here's mine:

5. Derrick Favors- A-
Click to expand...

I agree with all your grades except Favors'. What you did is like a professor having a student who didn't do well in an exam and, instead of giving him the deserved C, you give him an A- because you know he had the flu.

My point is Favors performance was what it was. One can't really say how he would perform without the injuries. One can't grade a conjecture.
 
ghsartin said:
I agree with all your grades except Favors'. What you did is like a professor having a student who didn't do well in an exam and, instead of giving him the deserved C, you give him an A- because you know he had the flu.

My point is Favors performance was what it was. One can't really say how he would perform without the injuries. One can't grade a conjecture.
Click to expand...

We'll give him an I (incomplete).
 
1. George Hill- A+
2. Gordon Hayward- A
3. Rudy Gobert- A-
4. Rodney Hood- A-
5. Derrick Favors- B
6. Joel Bolomboy- C
7. Dante Exum- B
8. Joe Johnson- B
9. Jeff Withey- C
10. Shelvin Mack- C-
11. Trey Lyles- C-
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top