What's new

RIP Robin Williams

  • Thread starter Thread starter JAZZGASM
  • Start date Start date
I forgot to post this for some reason:

[video=youtube_share;5CTvjwt1bvY]https://youtu.be/5CTvjwt1bvY

As a final irony Williams did this song at the Oscars because the woman who sang it in the South Park movie committed suicide about 3 weeks earlier.
 
What argument? You said suicide is selfish. I am asking why you are asking an irrational person to be unselfish. How hard is that to answer?

Jim, here's the problem with what you're saying. You seem to think that I'm trying to convince a mentally ill person that committing suicide is a selfish act to keep them from killing themselves…I'm not trying to convince them. Whether they think it is selfish or not is irrelevant.

The reason it's irrelevant is because as any healthy (mentally at least) person knows, suicide is selfish. That's all I'm saying. I certainly wouldn't tell somebody battling depression that I think it's selfish because of the logic reasons that we've talked about, but that doesn't mean that it isn't selfish.

Understand?
 
Jim, here's the problem with what you're saying. You seem to think that I'm trying to convince a mentally ill person that committing suicide is a selfish act to keep them from killing themselves…I'm not trying to convince them. Whether they think it is selfish or not is irrelevant.

The reason it's irrelevant is because as any healthy (mentally at least) person knows, suicide is selfish. That's all I'm saying. I certainly wouldn't tell somebody battling depression that I think it's selfish because of the logic reasons that we've talked about, but that doesn't mean that it isn't selfish.

Understand?
Is suicide still selfish if the person has no friends or family at all?

Is it selfish if the suicidal persons friends and family wish he wasn't in thier lives?

Just curious
 
Is suicide still selfish if the person has no friends or family at all?

Is it selfish if the suicidal persons friends and family wish he wasn't in thier lives?

Just curious

Personally, I think so, although I can understand why others might not.

I view life as a gift…who are we to take that away? There is always something positive you can do for somebody, always. Whether that is reciprocated or not is irrelevant, IMO.
 
Personally, I think so, although I can understand why others might not.

I view life as a gift…who are we to take that away? There is always something positive you can do for somebody, always. Whether that is reciprocated or not is irrelevant, IMO.

Quite the selfish viewpoint wanting others you don't know to give to you or humanity.
 
Personally, I think so, although I can understand why others might not.

I view life as a gift…who are we to take that away? There is always something positive you can do for somebody, always. Whether that is reciprocated or not is irrelevant, IMO.

Don't just preach it.
 
Back
Top