What's new

Mother Mistakes Daughter for Intruder, Shoots and Kills Her.

But the premise of gun ownership is the right to defend one self with it. If a certain part of the population cannot operate it safely, to me that's a cause of inequality. It's a matter of principle as well as practicality.
Defend oneself from criminals. Not from old lady neighbors. What a ridiculous take this is.
 
Defend oneself from criminals. Not from old lady neighbors. What a ridiculous take this is.

But who are these 'criminals'? Often times they're just everyday people like us who make bad decisions.


If you're talking about serious criminals and gangs and such then that's what the police are for.
 
Defend oneself from criminals. Not from old lady neighbors. What a ridiculous take this is.

Is Oscar Pistorius a criminal? He's just another guy who's allowed to own a gun but decides to use that gun to kill his GF.


He wasn't a criminal until he decided to fire that gun.
 
Is Oscar Pistorius a criminal? He's just another guy who's allowed to own a gun but decides to use that gun to kill his GF.


He wasn't a criminal until he decided to fire that gun.

Stop. Please stop. For your sake. For ours. Just stop.
 
Stop. Please stop. For your sake. For ours. Just stop.

Debate the point please. This idea that there are 'criminals' out there we need to protect ourselves against. The 'criminals' are none other than ordinary people who are allowed to own guns but uses them for criminal acts.
 
But who are these 'criminals'? Often times they're just everyday people like us who make bad decisions.
Really? How about showing me some evidence of all of these everyday people who snap and turn their guns on their neighbors. Your apparent impression that this is some standoff is entirely incorrect.


If you're talking about serious criminals and gangs and such then that's what the police are for.
Hello police, a gang just came by and murdered me and my family. Could you take care of that, please?
 
Debate the point please. This idea that there are 'criminals' out there we need to protect ourselves against. The 'criminals' are none other than ordinary people who are allowed to own guns but uses them for criminal acts.

The great thing about being an adult is that I don't need to explain myself to someone who has zero ****ing clue as to what they're talking about. If you don't get it by now, you probably never will.
 
Oscar Pistorius?
Wow. One example, and it didn't even happen in America. In addition, his girlfriend apparently forgot to carry her gun because as you say, it's not fair for him to have one to shoot her and her not to have one to shoot him back.

This conversation is pointless. The reasons you are claiming that people want to own guns does not match the reason that they actually own guns.
 
Wow. One example, and it didn't even happen in America. In addition, his girlfriend apparently forgot to carry her gun because as you say, it's not fair for him to have one to shoot her and her not to have one to shoot him back.

This conversation is pointless. The reasons you are claiming that people want to own guns does not match the reason that they actually own guns.

Ok but you can't say definitively that all gun owners have good intentions for owning guns... (even if the majority do have good intentions).
 
Oscar Pistorius?
Oscar Pistorius actually had a history of using his gun in completely irresponsible ways. At a restaurant he was showing it off and "accidentally" fired a round. He got a speeding ticket and as he drive away he stuck his gun out the window and popped off a few rounds to demonstrate his frustration. He shouldn't have had a gun. At all.
 
OL old ladies can use guns effectively. In fact, they could use a gun far more effectively than they could use a bat or knife.

The four basic rules of firearm safety are just that. The very most basic rules to make sure guns are used safely. In fact, you must violate at least two of the four rules in order to cause unintended harm. No one should possess a gun without knowing and committing to those rules. Every gun owner's manual I've ever seen has those rules printed.
 
OL old ladies can use guns effectively. In fact, they could use a gun far more effectively than they could use a bat or knife.

The four basic rules of firearm safety are just that. The very most basic rules to make sure guns are used safely. In fact, you must violate at least two of the four rules in order to cause unintended harm. No one should possess a gun without knowing and committing to those rules. Every gun owner's manual I've ever seen has those rules printed.

Yeah look I'm not trying to step on anyone's toes here.. there are plenty of good gun owners and clearly you and Joe are two of the very best examples. In the perfect world every gun owner would known these basic rules, can handle the gun and use them safely and all have good intentions (i.e., for defense only, not to provoke).


All I'm saying is in reality the world isn't perfect. Not all gun owners can use guns safely and effectively. Not all gun owners have good intentions, all the time neither. Also I don't think we can pretend all gun owners are mentally stable... and so on and so forth.


Personally I'm confident that once trained I'd be able to handle a gun confidently and safely... But I do meet a lot of old ladies through my nursery daily and I'm just not so sure these ladies who are in their 80's and have arthritis & trembling hands can do it.
 
Game actually had a good start to this thread.

If you want to learn to live right in any respect, it starts with taking responsibility. There's always some helpful rules that can be applied whatever you're doing. I want that responsibility for myself.
 
Back
Top