At their best, I would pick AK a hundred times over. Transcendental player with a unique skillset.
That 03/04 season. Oh man. On a 42-win team, AK had more winshares than Hayward last year. He was fifth in the league that year. Read that again, fifth in the ****ing league! Andrei's +/- over 100 possessions was 8.2. Hayward was 4.2 last year. Value over replacement player? Andrei was 7.5. Everyone else on that Jazz team but Greg Ostertag(!) was under 1.0. Hayward last year? 4.0.
Also, take a look at rosters they both had in 03/04 and 15/16. Andrei led a roster of borderline NBA players to 42-40. Hayward couldn't lead the team to .500 the year before.
This is why I have so much hate for Deron Williams and hope he ends up a homeless alcoholic. Not only did he kill Jerry Sloan's love of basketball, we ruined a generational player in order to turn the team over to him.