Moonstruck out here in Asbury Park, NJ.
Meh. Very mixed bag. It's a very recognized, respected restaurant in my area (which is a hotbed for food) but my wife and I found it average. We got an app as we sat by the bar, waiting for our table. Lamb Quesadillas with feta cheese, olives, tomato and yogurt tzatziki. Meh. Thin. Could barely make out any lamb. We were then seated and got a butternut squash soup and another dish to start. My wife thought the soup was just average. I found it better than that. I'd give it a B. But it was missing something. A little spice. My mother who is an extraordinary cook has made one before that's the best I ever had. I know she puts a little pepper in it. That would've helped. We also got Whipped Fresh Ricotta with a honey drizzle, wine poached pears, toasted almonds, aged balsamico, cracked pepper and crostini. That was very good. A solid A-. I thought the crostini could have been herbed or fresher but my wife found that insignificant as it's the conduit to the ricotta. Whatever. Splitting hairs. It was still very good regardless. For an entree, my wife got a rigatoni with pumpkin & goat cheese sautéed with scallion, butter, cream, sage & roasted walnuts and topped w/ toasted breadcrumbs. I had some and we both found it excellent though the pumpkin (chunks) a bit hard. Not sure if you can cook that longer and make it softer but it's sort of an odd eat. Overall though, the dish was great. I ordered a grilled ribeye that came with fries and chipotle ketchup. Mistake. This is the second or third time I've ordered a ribeye from a non-steakhouse and every time I regret it. It was medicore at best. It was cooked medium rare like I asked but there was basically no flavor so the cut sort of sucked as did the chef who cooked it. The fries were even bad too. Thin ones that tasted microwaved. I'll go back again within the next year but will be sure to order something more Italian as that's the restaurant's wheelhouse. We then each got desserts. Both were very good. Overall, I'd give the place a B-/C+. Great ambiance though very loud. But the food was a bit hit or miss.