*****SPOILERS****
Just finished the series today. I have been thinking about it quite a bit and here are my thoughts.
- First question that pops into my head is why was Koob the first person Sister Russell called when Sister Cathy went missing? Any normal person would think to call the police.
Maybe bceause Sister Russell has only been out of the sisterhood and living in the outside world for a short time? I can understand why she would have consulted a trusted male in Koob first.
- The way they acted that night was extremely weird as well. They were breaking bread and saved her a piece. They prayed and everything but didn't think to go look for her?
Again, remember that these are people of STRONG faith, and praying would have been a perfectly normal activity IMO.
- Koob comes off as very odd to me. The scene where he said the detective threw Cathy's vagina wrapped in newspaper on the table was extremely weird to me.
Agreed. But I wonder if it's just an interrogation tactic? It didn't needed to be Cathy's, it could have been anybody's just to get Koob's reaction?
- Does anyone else think Skippy could be Edgar?
Interesting - need to re-watch.
- Does anyone else think Brother Bob could be Koob?
Interesting - need to re-watch.
- I have no words to describe how disgusting and ****ed up of a person Maskell was. He abused the kids trust in him and used their horrible past experiences against them. Then he had the audacity to say he really thought he was helping them? Are you ****ing kidding me?
As bad and as evil as Maskell was, it was the Church's response to this tragedy that is to me is the saddest part. They 'created' an environment in which something like this could have happened. How was he able to have an office where he counselled young girls behind locked doors? It doesn't matter how 'Saint like' you are. What kind of system is that?
- Edgar admits that he was the person to call in on the radio show. That alone makes him seem like he was involved somehow.
- The gift that he gave his wife had an August birthstone which matched the birth month of the husband of Sister Cathy's sister.
- The scene where Billy's ex-wife said he wouldn't stop talking about the lady upstairs so she went up there and there was a nun outfit on a manikin. That freaked me out and was extremely creepy.
Yup, that scene was one of the creepiest of all these true crime docs I've watched. And I've watched A LOT of them.
- The Catholic church is a joke. The way they were protecting Maskell and fighting the bill made me so mad. **** them.
Agreed.
- Sharon May is the shadiest bitch I've ever seen in my entire life. She had the nerve to lie and say the files they dug up had nothing in them to charge Maskell with? Why did he bury them then? It makes no sense especially when someone says they physically saw pictures.
Agreed. She's a real snake.
- The police have one piece of evidence found at the crime scene which is the cigarette butt. They dug up Maskell's body and it wasn't a match. I didn't think it would be but I'm interested to find out if it matches any of the suspects.
I hope that because of this they try and match it with more people than Maskell. I never thought it would have matched Maskell. He was the puppeteer, he didn't get his hands dirty.
Sorry for the long post but I have so many thoughts about this series.
Sent from my iPhone using
JazzFanz mobile app
