Let me clarify a few things because I think my post was taken wrong: I'm not coming out and saying BYU isn't that good after week 2. Should they run the table, obviously there's a chance for a nice bowl game and positive momentum heading in to next year if Hill returns. I was speaking solely about the possibility of BYU running the table this year and being left out of the 4 team playoff. Obviously, going undefeated is NEVER a bad thing, regardless of schedule strength. I have no idea how BYU's schedule looks next year but if it's stronger than this season, there's a great chance for them to build on this season and possibly do something special next year. If it's as weak as this season, you guys are gonna have a ton of detractors across the nation claiming that you had a nice 2 year run, but you didn't play anybody. Plus, with your current SOS, you guys can't have 1 single mistep. An off night against Boise or UCF and you guys are a one loss time playing in a lower bowl game.
The bottom line still hasn't changed: BYU has to find their way into a conference. As an independent, they either play a schedule that's so strong, any team would struggle to go undefeated, or they play one so soft, that there's a huge asterisk by their record. You're right about Utah. They did use those special seasons to propel themselves into a bigger conference. Will BYU be able to do the same?