What's new

2024 NBA Draft Reaction Thread

Well without the half tank you don't have the Lakers pick and you probably don't have Filipowski or Collier on the team. Does that change your analysis?
The problem is that we don't really know what an alternative universe would look like and what other opportunities we might have had had we gone full tank for example. Maybe we get even more/better picks for Conley, Ochai, Bogdanovic/KO, NAW, etc. or maybe not. The reports at the time(if I'm not mistaken) were that we could have had that Lakers pick if we wanted it in October... we just wanted more... and we didn't get it. Similar with other trades.
 
The problem is that we don't really know what an alternative universe would look like and what other opportunities we might have had had we gone full tank for example. Maybe we get even more/better picks for Conley, Ochai, Bogdanovic/KO, NAW, etc. or maybe not. The reports at the time(if I'm not mistaken) were that we could have had that Lakers pick if we wanted it in October... we just wanted more... and we didn't get it. Similar with other trades.
Lmfao y'all are unreal
 
Lmfao y'all are unreal
Why? What's your objection? You only want to present one side of the argument and one set of incoming assets as if if we didn't do this and exactly this, we couldn't get anything close in value. This is a bunch of nonsense. Those players had value whether in July or in February. Why are you acting like if we traded them in July we would have only gotten what? A bunch of expirings/trade exceptions?
 
Why? What's your objection? You only want to present one side of the argument and one set of incoming assets as if if we didn't do this and exactly this, we couldn't get anything close in value. This is a bunch of nonsense. Those players had value whether in July or in February. Why are you acting like if we traded them in July we would have only gotten what? A bunch of expirings/trade exceptions?
Because this has been gone over at length and you seem to want to re-litigate the past because it turns out the Jazz made the right moves and now all your incessant bitching about "no plan" looks ridiculous
 
Because this has been gone over at length and you seem to want to re-litigate the past because it turns out the Jazz made the right moves and now all your incessant bitching about "no plan" looks ridiculous
Huh? I think it is pretty clear that we could have gotten at least similar value if we had made those same trades prior to both seasons rather than at mid-season. The big difference being that if we make the trades prior to the season we are probably looking at our own draft pick being closer to 5 than 10 the last few seasons.
 
Huh? I think it is pretty clear that we could have gotten at least similar value if we had made those same trades prior to both seasons rather than at mid-season. The big difference being that if we make the trades prior to the season we are probably looking at our own draft pick being closer to 5 than 10 the last few seasons.
Again, no interest in arguing with people who can't even remember the reality of the Conley situation
 
Because this has been gone over at length and you seem to want to re-litigate the past because it turns out the Jazz made the right moves and now all your incessant bitching about "no plan" looks ridiculous
No it doesn't look ridiculous. And I don't want to relitigate anything. This team has had no plan the last 2 years. Your GM(or whatever his official role is) told you that. We've been floaitng around the last 2 years. This doesn't mean every decision along the way is bad(for example, I obviously like a lot of those draft picks). But huge majority of those picks(or similar value had we done earlier deals) were there to be had pretty much no matter what we did. Right now this rebuild is being carried by those 2 initial deals. And lets not act like those prospects we have are even a sure thing. Yes some of them look promising... others haven't played a minute in the league yet. In 2 years all of those might look like complete busts... I seriously have no idea based on what exactly are you taking victory laps?
 
Well without the half tank you don't have the Lakers pick and you probably don't have Filipowski or Collier on the team. Does that change your analysis?

That’s a different conversation. Nothing changes my opinion on the results based analysis. I prefer to be process oriented. I’m not going to judge the “half tank” on things that are up to complete luck.

I’m sure that if we had gone tankers paradise route we would also have things that were of value.
 
We really got posters who think we could have gotten the Lakers top 4 protected 2027 pick in the summer for Conley after he was coming off the worst post season performance of his career? Everyone thought Conley was washed. Just insane how much people forget.
 
That’s a different conversation. Nothing changes my opinion on the results based analysis. I prefer to be process oriented. I’m not going to judge the “half tank” on things that are up to complete luck.

I’m sure that if we had gone tankers paradise route we would also have things that were of value.
The process of full tanking quite literally hinges on luck more than any other strategy....

I feel like yr just typing words hoping it sound smart at this point.
 
That’s a different conversation. Nothing changes my opinion on the results based analysis. I prefer to be process oriented. I’m not going to judge the “half tank” on things that are up to complete luck.

I’m sure that if we had gone tankers paradise route we would also have things that were of value.
No you don't get it. If we tank all our players dissolve into thin air and you can't get anything for them. It's either LAL pick, Filipowski and Collier or NOTHING! Yes. You get nothing for Conley, Bogdanovic/KO, Ochai, Beasley, Vanderbilt, NAW... the 2 second round picks... those just disappear...
 
The process of tanking quite literally hinges on luck more than any other strategy....

Right….which is why I don’t use results based analysis. If you simply get really lucky or unlucky, it doesn’t mean the plan was better or worse to begin with.

There was a small chance we lost our pick entirely, there was also a small chance we win the lottery and get the #1 pick. Point is, it’s the same plan.
 
Back
Top