I'm a BYU fan AND a big CJ-critic and I wouldn't do that trade. Miles is inconsistent, but he can at least bother opposing SG's with his size.
Jimmer is a great college basketball star. I just don't think his game will translate into the NBA. He's a classic "tweener" - too small to be a SG, not quick enough to be a PG. Jimmer is kind of like Mo Williams, but without the quickness. I like Jimmer as a college player and as a person. He seems to be great guy and a fierce competitor. But he's also just 6'2." No question he'd be a top-3 pick if he were 6'4"-6'5." But I don't see him having success against the smaller, quicker PG's like Rose, Westbrook, Paul, etc. At best, Jimmer will be a backup combo guard. Not sure that's the upside you want with a lottery pick. In Hayward's defense, he at least has the size and ball-handling skills to develop into a starter. As a 4-year college player, Jimmer's not going to grow another 3 inches, nor does he have as much upside.
s