Bean, you do know Utah plays 12 games right?
I didn't vote for BYU because, well, because I refuse to but they will clearly have a better record than Utah due to scheduling. Thanks to BYU's more stable QB situation I would also say that BYU will probably be better overall than Utah (please hold while I throw up in my mouth a little). Ok, now that that's over with, a few more BYU-Utah predictions for the upcoming season:
-Utah could possibly have the better team if Jordan Wynn comes back truly healthy and if he shows he has a firm grasp of Chow's offense early on. Granted, those are some pretty big "if's", but if that indeed ended up being the case, I'd give Utah a slight nod as the better team. At this point it's almost a given that Utah will field better athletes across the board over BYU. Especially at skill positions such as WR's and CB's/Safeties. Even though Utah is going to be young in the defensive backfield, I'll take what they have over BYU in that area each and every time. I also think Utah has a better D-line rotation and with JD Williams hopefully healthy at LB, I think Utah wins in that area too. Blechen is a freak and I think the move to LB will prove to be a great one. Overall, I think Utah is "clearly" better than BYU defensively, the big question will be is if their offense can bridge the gap enough to make them the better overall team.
-I think Utah will lose @ BYU this year (but I'm still going to bet Trout). I HATE where this game is on the schedule for the UTES. Playing @USC a week earlier in their first ever Pac12 game sets the BYU game up to a be pretty tough one. Not to mention BYU gets Utah in their home opener. Even if BYU splits the first 2 games (even with Texas down, I don't see BYU winning there), coming home 1-and-1 is going to make the Utah game feel like a must win for the Cougs.
-With all that being said, I still wouldn't trade places with BYU. Even if Utah started the season 1-and-2 with losses to USC and BYU, there is still SOOO much more to play for. Utah could finish the season strong and gain a bid to the Holiday Bowl, which IMO would have to be considered a huge success during year 1 of Pac12 play. Hell, with USC on probation, Utah could lose to them and still have a chance to win the Pac12 South. In the end, I think if all things come together for Utah they can win 8 games. So my official prediction is 8-4 with a bowl victory.
-I think BYU will win 9 or 10 games, but so what? The instant BYU loses- even if it's as early as week 1 or 2, they then get to go the majority of the season knowing that no matter what they do, they'll be playing in the Armed Forces Bowl. The BCS is most likely never going to take a 1 loss BYU squad, so until BYU runs the table or finds a conference, that's what they're looking at. My guess is that unless Holmoe finds some serious Bowl upgrades to tie in with, BYU fans are going to get frustrated pretty quickly. I will be the first to say that the move to independence was the right one for BYU, and it looks like they're doing pretty good in getting some future big games on the schedule, but honestly, how much intrigue can a season hold when you know that the second your team loses a game, it's instantly a ticket to the Armed Forces Bowl?