Deron Williams fits into the category of a couple all-star/allnba appearances. Same with Russell Westbrook, Love, and Blake. They are not superstars. Your data proves my point further. Lebron, Paul, wade, Garnett, these are superstars.
Right now Deron Williams fits the category of T-Mac. Would have could have injury bug. But I honestly disagree with your assessment. Love has a monster offensive output(2nd both in points and rebounds) and if Melo is a superstar then Love is just as much(when healthy).
Wade IMO is no superstar. He's good but overhyped. His body is completely washed since some time. He had a lucky punch assisted by refs in 2006. But after that his teams didn't do much and he spent a lot of time injured until LeBron came to town. So your definition doesn't fit the player you sort into it. Same with Garnett. W/o big three he didn't do much his last years in Minny. But the way you present yourself I don't see you being open for arguments.